Does Kamala hate Catholics?

"In 2018, she attacked Brian C. Buescher, a federal district court nominee, over his membership in the Knights of Columbus, a 142-year-old Catholic fraternal organization dedicated to public service," wrote Vance, suggesting she intended to paint the judge as unfit for office due to his Catholic faith.

Harris was also criticized for her 2019 "Do No Harm Act," which would have reduced the ability of religiously affiliated healthcare providers to refuse abortion, contraception, and other government-contracted medical services.

Finally, Vance took aim at her current role as second-in-command to President Joe Biden, under whom the FBI surveilled traditionalist Catholics for alleged connections to violent extremism. The Department of Justice also brought charges against a Catholic anti-abortion activist in 2022 following a skirmish with a Planned Parenthood worker in Pennsylvania. (He was later acquitted.)

"As a Catholic myself, I have a personal investment in ending this consistent pattern of anti-Catholic policies and actions," Vance wrote. "But even non-Catholics and nonreligious Americans should be alarmed."

Despite Vance’s claims, his op-ed doesn’t quite tell the whole story on Harris’ intersection with the Catholic Church. Dating back to her time as a university student in Washington, she has been notably open to certain wings of the Church — including visits to St. Augustine, the "mother church" of Black Catholics in the nation’s capital. Harris’ family also has ties to Catholic education, with her sister Maya having attended Bishop O’Dowd High School in their native Oakland, California.

During her tenure as San Francisco district attorney and later as California attorney general, Harris came under fire for her decisions related to the Catholic clergy child sex abuse crisis. In 2019, she admitted to withholding documents related to abuse cases from attorneys and the media — though, she claimed, to protect the identities of victims.

Many of the abused and their attorneys criticized Harris’ decision, noting that the names could be redacted as needed. In the end, "She did nothing," according to the Northern California spokesman for the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. Political experts said she was likely wary of possibly alienating certain sectors of the California Catholic electorate.

Moreover, on the national scale, it is spurious to argue that Harris will struggle with the "Catholic vote" due to any supposed discrimination. Though swing-state Catholics generally lean conservative, Black and Hispanic Catholics nationally are planning to vote for Harris — as they did to great effect in 2020.

Also of note is that the supposedly anti-Catholic Harris is running alongside a former Catholic in Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, who was congratulated by the Minnesota Catholic Conference upon securing the VP nomination in August.

Overall, Harris’ Catholic supporters have not budged from the position that she represents Catholic values more so than Trump, which may be seen at this point as a toss-up. Both major parties are at odds with Church teaching on various issues, and even Trump’s wife, Melania, has openly associated herself with the American Catholic dissensus on issues like abortion access. 

On the topic of actual anti-Catholicism, it was just this week that one of Trump’s own operatives falsely maligned a group of progressive nuns for voter fraud. (He apparently did not know that women religious often live — and early vote — in large numbers from a single address.) Vance and Trump have also spent much of the past month vilifying and threatening Ohio’s Haitians, one of the most Catholic demographics in Black America.

As such, it remains to be seen which of the two major party candidates is committed to a genuinely positive stance toward U.S. Catholics and their Church’s beliefs, which often do not cleanly intersect. Until Nov. 5, though, it’s likely that a certain convenient tune will continue to ring out from the GOP.