Married priests and women deacons: NCR's top 10 most read opinion of 2024

2. Editorial: Cardinal Dolan's 'Al Smith dinner' disappointment is misdirected

New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan was disappointed in the rejection from Vice President Kamala Harris, the Democratic candidate for president, of his invitation to the annual Al Smith charity dinner. But the National Catholic Reporter's editorial staff was disappointed that Dolan did not have the courage to stand up to Donald Trump.

"The real controversy is that an event that touts its history of raising funds for society's most needy is going to host someone who is one of the culture's greatest threats to that kind of caring," we wrote. "The real outrage is that Trump, given the public nature and extent of his repulsive record, should be invited to a fundraiser for an organization, Catholic Charities, that has long worked in the trenches to save and transform lives on society's farthest margins. It is tragic that the guest of honor this year will be someone whose personal example and policy wishes are in a collision course with the principles of Catholic social teaching."

3. Catholic students, theologians, ministers write an open letter to Pope Francis

After the publication of Dignitas Infinita, Pope Francis' document that addresses sex change operations, gender theory and surrogate motherhood, dozens of Catholic students, theologians and ministers wrote an open letter to the pope criticizing the document.

"We love this church, we love our Catholic faith," but "personally, professionally and ministerially, we are concerned with Dignitas Infinita's statements on gender theory and sex change," they wrote. "We implore you to hear the cries of transgender, nonbinary and intersex people. As a church, we cannot love who we do not truly know."

4. A busy week for three potential future popes

In this analysis, NCR Vatican correspondent Christopher White draws attention to three potential future popes having their moment in the spotlight while Francis got some much-needed rest in the summer before the longest international trip of his papacy.

"While cardinals are forbidden from waging a campaign for the papacy, major public events or news surrounding them can't help but to raise their profiles both among fellow church leaders and ordinary Catholics alike," White wrote. "While eventual ballots will be cast in the Sistine Chapel in secret, the public scrutiny of possible candidates began long ago."

5. Anonymous Catholic cardinal argues for a next pope very unlike Francis

An unidentified Catholic cardinal authored a scathing memo in March, saying Francis has sown "confusion" in the church and arguing that the next conclave should elect a very different kind of pontiff.

"The new document begins with conciliatory language that praises Francis' outreach to the poor and marginalized, though it quickly pivots to its criticism of his style of governance and the pope's approach to fundamental questions of faith and morals," White writes in his analysis. "One detects that the author seems to want to make a broad case for a course correction in the next conclave, while attracting potentially sympathetic cardinals to come along with him."

6. If women cannot be deacons, we should stop ordaining men deacons

Francis expressed firm opposition to the idea of ordaining Catholic women as deacons in a U.S. television interview on May 20 with CBS' Norah O'Donnell, raising doubts that the ongoing three-year synodal process could move forward on the issue.

"Limiting the diaconate and priesthood to men is painful for many women in the church," Reese wrote in this August column, "but if we cannot ordain women as deacons, there is no reason we have to ordain men." 

7. On women deacons, the Catholic Church has to remember its own history

In November, Francis issued a letter "On the Renewal of the Study of the History of the Church," stressing the importance of studying church history so that priests can better interpret the world in which we live.

But Phyllis Zagano argued that Francis himself seems to have forgotten the history of women ordained as deacons.

"He seems to have slammed shut the door to recovering the church's tradition on deacons, simultaneously enabling the international walkout of women and men from Catholicism," Zagano wrote.

8. New book examines conservative Catholics, and it isn't pretty

NCR columnist Michael Sean Winters reviewed Francis Maier's True Confessions, which provides "an insider's look at the conservative wing of the Catholic Church."

"What Maier does not tell you, but which becomes evident pretty quickly, is that the lens of his camera only takes in a small — I had almost written narrow — slice of the picture of that church in this moment," wrote Winters.

9. How Pope Francis has changed the mission for Catholic colleges and universities

Francis' papacy has captured with great depth the value of the crossroads in which Catholic higher education finds itself, theologian Massimo Faggioli said in a keynote presentation given to the Jan. 11-13 conference at the University of San Diego on "Lighting the Way Forward: The Purpose of Catholic Higher Education in a Changing World."

"Certainly, a deeper reception of Francis' message is needed in our institutions, at all levels — faculty, administrators, alumni, and donors," Faggioli said. "This reception would help correct some misperceptions on the ecclesial and cultural challenges facing Catholic higher education in the world of today."

10. Editorial: Hope in a time of darkness

Following the election of Trump as the nation's 47th president, the NCR editorial staff wrote about finding hope in a time of darkness.

"As active witnesses of justice and mercy, we will transform darkness into light and weakness into strength for ourselves and others," we wrote. "Every act of love, every gesture of kindness and healing builds the nation that, for now, seems to elude us."