Pope unveils African Synod preparation paper

Mar. 19, 2009
Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly versionSend to friendSend to friendPDF versionPDF version

Yaoundè, Cameroon

While some Catholics in the West seem entirely comfortable fighting the church’s internal culture wars – featuring endless rows over liturgy, doctrine, and authority – others have long breathed a weary sigh about such matters, regarding preoccupation with them mostly as an exercise in navel-gazing.

That kind of Catholic is generally more interested in changing the world rather than tinkering with the church.

For anyone who feels that way, the instrumentum laboris, or “working paper,” for the upcoming Synod for Africa, presented by Pope Benedict XVI today in Cameroon, will likely come as a massive breath of fresh air. In ecclesiastical language, the working paper is a deliberately ad extra document, concentrating on how the gospel message can transform the broader culture.

Speaking of the church in Africa, the working paper declares that “she ought not to retire into herself,” and calls for a “more prophetic role” in the social and political life of the continent.

The official theme of the synod, set for October in Rome, is “The Church in Africa in Service to Reconciliation, Justice and Peace,” setting a tone that runs through the 62-page document. While there is passing mention of more internal questions such as Eucharistic adoration, the overwhelming thrust is to marshal the church’s resources to end war and to promote democracy, human rights, and the rule of law in African societies, as well as to carve out more just relationships with the outside world.

October’s synod is styled as a follow-up to the first Synod for Africa, which took place in 1994. Coincidentally, the synod met in Rome just as genocidal violence began to explode in Rwanda – a harrowing reminder of the threats to peace and stability on the continent, as well as the limits of the church’s capacity to influence events. (Prior to the genocide, an estimated 62 percent of Rwanda’s population of 7.8 million was Catholic.)

Although the pope presented the working paper today, in reality it’s less his voice expressed in its pages than that of the African church. The instrumentum laboris was prepared by a commission composed largely of African bishops, and it expresses the agenda of the African church for the synod.

“Seen among the vast numbers of the elect are infirm, the poor, the enslaved, widows, foreigners, migrants and persons on the periphery of African society,” the document says. “These are the very recipients of God’s preferential love, so much so that the Lord Jesus identifies himself with them.”

The document calls the church in Africa to a “mission of peace,” asserting that “this mission has never been more timely in Africa, because of her conflicts, wars and violence.”

(According to the United Nations, out of 13 million deaths in large-scale conflicts around the world since 1994, more than 9 million have come in sub-Saharan Africa. The continent is also home to several million refugees and internally displaced persons, according to the U.N. High Commission for Refugees.)

An illustrative, but by no means exhaustive, list of matters the working paper wants the synod to tackle includes:

“Greed, corruption and the allurement of gain.” (The African Union estimates that pervasive corruption in many states costs Africa an average of $150 billion every year, equivalent to one-quarter of Africa’s total Gross Domestic Product.)

  • Human rights and democracy
  • “Globalization,” which, the working paper asserts, “is tending to marginalize Africa.”
  • The family
  • The dignity of women, and contemporary threats to that dignity – including “problems of inheritance and rites of widowhood, sexual mutilation, forced marriages and polygamy.”
  • Ethnocentrism, xenophobia and tribal and regional conflict
  • Low prices for indigenous products, difficult obtaining credit for small and micro-businesses, a lack of infrastructure and decent roads, growing unemployment, and the phenomenon of “wage slavery”
  • Urbanization and the depopulation of rural areas
  • Growing crime
  • Exploitation of natural resources for the benefit of elites
  • Climate change and the environment
  • The financial crisis and international economic structures
  • Violence and war, and the arms trade
  • The death penalty, torture, and delays in the justice system
  • Witchcraft and superstitious forms of religion
  • Support for farm workers and opposition to genetically modified organisms) (GMOs

One clear emphasis of the document is that the church’s contribution to tackling these problems should not be simply a matter of bishops’ conferences issuing statements, but also that lay faithful working in politics, finance, and other sectors ought to transform African societies from the inside out.

To be sure, all this activism is grounded in a spiritual frame of reference. The working paper acknowledges that the ultimate basis for the ills of African societies, as in other parts of the world, is “the wounded human heart.” Pastoral efforts aimed at individual conversion and holiness, it says, therefore remain an indispensable priority.

Nonetheless, the list above is more than enough to make the point that the Synod for Africa seems destined to have a horizon that extends well beyond the four walls of the church sacristy.

(Allen is NCR senior correspondent. His e-mail address is jallen@ncronline.org.)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

John Allen is in Africa covering Pope Benedict XVI’s March 17-23 trip to Cameroon and Angola. Watch the NCR web site for his daily reports.

Reports he has already filed include:

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Just because the Vatican

Just because the Vatican doesn't want to address the evidently common practices of concubinage and lack of valuing celibacy within the clergy ranks, doesn't mean that the problem doesn't exist and isn't more commonly practiced than readily admitted.

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5g9o5FfAWPymsj2IxYBg-Cl...

“Some Catholic priests in Africa also ignore the church requirement that they take a vow of celibacy.

"Priests having affairs is rampant in the church" in South Africa, said Velesiwe Mkwanazi, a former Catholic lay leader who co-founded Women Ordination South Africa and says she knows two priests with children.

"Parishioners blame women, say we seduce the priests, but we are brought up to respect and honor men, and women can't say no to a priest who is held up to us as a fount of knowledge in daily communication with God," she said.

Co-founder Dina Cormick said priests who are caught having affairs are sent on retreats or moved to other parishes while nuns caught in sexual liaisons with priests are forced to leave their orders.

The Rev. Rodney Moss, the head of St. Augustine College, South Africa's only Catholic university, would say only that "a lot more effort is being put into dealing with problems of sexuality in seminaries. When I was a seminarian it was hardly addressed, but now there is quite a lot said about it."

The Rev. Simangaliso Mkhatshwa, a priest who is also a leading member of South Africa's governing African National Congress, said the church needs to have an open discussion about celibacy.

"It's an issue that needs to be more openly discussed among lay people, priests among themselves, the bishops in this country, but also internationally," he said. "Because some of these policies probably were designed for a particular era and it does happen from time to time we have to ask whether some of these policies are still relevant."
Others believe the church needs to go further.

"If we want to stop the scandal of ... children (born out of wedlock to priests), then we must change the thinking," said Mike Auret, who worked for Zimbabwe's Catholic Bishops' Conference for more than 20 years. "Lay Catholic leaders have been talking about marriage for priests for years."

Zimbabwean Archbishop Pius Ncube admitted having an affair with a married parishioner and stepped down in 2007 after state media broadcast images purporting to show him undressing and naked in his bedroom with a woman.
The Vatican said Ncube's resignation was accepted under a church law that says a bishop should retire if he is ill or if "some other grave reason" makes him unsuitable for office. The statement did not address the reputed affair; Ncube now works in a rural parish.

The Pope's document seems a

The Pope's document seems a very good one. But, are the African bishops incapable of producing their own? The revival of bishops' synods by Vatican II was meant to restore collegiality, the idea that the Church is governed by the college of bishops, not just the Roman curia. But Benedict XVI, following the example of John Paul II, has reversed all that. Now each synod's agenda is set by Rome and announced by Rome -- as today. Rome remains very much in control. Perhaps this is why most of the synods in recent years have been noncontroversial non-events.

Until the institutional

Until the institutional Church cleans up its own "internal culture" at all levels, it really has little or no credibility or moral authority to speak AD EXTRA! The "breath of fresh air" from Rome Mr. Allen touts here, still has a lingering morning mouth stench precisely because of many of the issues he chooses to dismiss as "navel-gazing."
A more critical reading of the ambitiously overreaching Instrumentum Laboris in search of actual substance (rather than favor-currying sound-bytes to meet a deadline) reveals that the purpose here is precisely to DIVERT public attention and negative media coverage AWAY FROM the "four walls of the church sacristy;" and to absolve the African episcopate from too close a self-scrutiny of its own "internal culture," lest those in high places actually be discovered as they either actively collaborate with or passively acquiesce to the continuing oppression of the African continent and its peoples.

As John Allen reports, the

As John Allen reports, the African Synod's Preparation pPaper calls for a more prophetic role in the social and political life of the continent. Tell that to all the prophetic voices which the Vatican has and continues to excommunicate, silence, or marginalize. Christ said that prophets are not accepted in their own country. So true! The life of a prophet proclaiming peace and justice in the Catholic Church is very short.

The Preparation Paper calls for an end to delays in African justice systems. What about the Church's own justice system where cases languish untouched for years, even decades, in the gathering dust of the "system"? Isn't his hypocracy at its worst?

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <font> <swf> <swf list>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may use <swf file="song.mp3"> to display Flash files inline

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This is prove you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Solve the simple math problem.
13 + 3 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.