The Independent News Source
NCR on Kindle - NCR classifieds - YouTube - Twitter - Facebook - Email Alerts - RSS
PDF versionKorean Catholic priests become Anglican and marry
Dec. 02, 2009
SEOUL, South Korea -- The Catholic Church in South Korea has lost four priests to the Anglicans in recent years, with marriage cited as the most important reason.
"They want to marry and at the same time serve as pastors," Anglican Fr. Peter Lee Kyong-nae, a former Catholic seminarian, told the Asian church news agency UCA News. Two more Catholic priests are currently preparing to become Anglican priests, he added.
While the buzz in the Catholic Church around the world concerns Pope Benedict XVI's decision to make it easier for Anglicans to become Catholics, in Korea there is some movement in the opposite direction.
"The priests made an honest and courageous decision to leave the Catholic Church in order to build a family, and they gave up all the privileges they enjoyed in the Catholic Church," Fr. Lee told UCA News.
Fr. Abraham Kim Gwang-joon, secretary-general of the provincial office of the Anglican Church of Korea, confirmed that the Catholic Church's requirement of celibacy was a major factor in the priests' decision.
"There are various personal reasons, but marriage is the most important," he said.
UCA News contacted two of the former Catholic priests, but they did not wish to comment on their decision.
It is not difficult for Catholic priests to join the Anglican clergy, although they must go through a screening process and study Anglican theology for a year.
"The Anglican Church sees the Catholic Church as a brother church inherited from the apostles, so we recognize Catholic priestly ordination as valid as ours," Fr. Lee explained. He added that the former Catholic priests enjoy a good reputation in his church.
Priestly celibacy was a hot discussion topic after Pope Benedict XVI recently made it easier for Anglicans to join the Catholic Church.
The apostolic constitution "Anglicanorum Coetibus" ("Groups of Anglicans"), issued by the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith Nov. 9, allows married Anglican priests to be ordained Catholic priests on "a case by case basis." Only celibate bishops will be allowed to be consecrated as Catholic bishops.
According to the "Complementary Norms" accompanying the apostolic constitution, Catholic priests who had become Anglicans will not be allowed to join the "personal ordinariates" -- the new church jurisdictions for Anglicans wishing to enter the Catholic Church -- as priests.
Many of those priests making the move from Anglicanism to Catholicism are doing so because they disagree with the ordination of women and the recognition of homosexual priests in the Anglican Church.
NCR: February 3-16, 2012
Subscribe to NCR to get all the news and special features that aren't always available online. In this issue:
- US News: Bishops Host Conference on Immigration
Conference fields advocates' questions on law, policy
- Special Section: Deacons. Serving as parish administrator; roles of wives; and more
- Study: Black Catholics are more engaged
New study by Notre Dame researcher about parish involvement in America
The Korean Anglican Church is relatively liberal on such matters, particularly the ordination of women, Fr. Lee says. It has ordained 14 women priests since 2001.
"Lots of elderly people are skeptical about the leadership of women priests, but as time goes by, the situation becomes better," he said. "But on homosexual priests, we do not recognize them yet."
The Anglican Church of Korea says it has 195 priests and three bishops tending to 50,000 laypeople in three dioceses.
Priestly celibacy should
Priestly celibacy should ALWAYS be optional, and of those priests who choose marriage and a family, we would have a healthier and more mature understanding of human sexuality and priesthood in the Catholic Church. It will not happen under Benedict's rule but it may very well happen under the next Bishop of Rome.
This is pretty consistent
This is pretty consistent everywhere. Catholic priests become Anglican to marry. Anglican priests become Catholic for matters of faith.
Some for matters of faith and
Some for matters of faith and some for personal prejudices. Let's be honest here.
It's happening here in the
It's happening here in the U.S. as well as in Korea. I was ordained for the Diocese of Brooklyn in 1959. About half our class of 36 left the canonical priesthood; two became Episcopal priests. As far as I'm aware, all of us left in order to marry...and all of us did.
Right here in Chapel Hill, NC, the rector of the local Episcopal church is a former Catholic priest...He is highly regarded, universally accepted, and happily married!
I never considered becoming an Episcopalian...My Irish mother would have considered it worse than my leaving the priesthood! Also, although my mother was at first devastated by my action, she quickly came to love my wife and children. Always a devout Catholic, she saw in her son's life the mysterious workings of a loving God.
Why not just leave - become
Why not just leave - become an Anglican Priest - get married - and come back?
The question that must be
The question that must be asked about those leaving is whether they truly meant the promises they made at their ordinations--or did just say yes but think "changes were a'comin."
There are so many married lay
There are so many married lay catholics who would if made welcome would love to try their vocation to the Anglican priesthood. I for one would . A cradle catholic, have alsways felt called to the \Priesthood but cant because I fell in love and have married. I live in the UK.
Post new comment