Our Matthew 25 duty on the US-Mexico border

Apr. 13, 2010
In this 2009 file photo, volunteers with the humanitarian group No More Deaths leave food and water for illegal immigrants crossing into the Arizona desert from Mexico. (CNS)

It was Holy Week, and we walked for miles through the desert. We hiked along ribbons of dirt paths, over parched rocky hills near the U.S.-Mexico border. The closest U.S. city was Tucson, Ariz., some 30 miles to the north.

Ours was an uncomplicated mission -- to place some 40 gallons of water where some of the thousands of sisters and brothers who cross the border at this "sector" can find them. It is a great risk for them to make this trek. Especially in the desert heat.

The attempt has killed 86 people since the first of October in the "Tucson sector" alone. In 2005, 216 died. Some froze to death, some died from injuries, others by thirst. And the death rate, according to authorities, has been dramatically rising. Even those who make it endure a harrowing, violent journey -- and face uncertainty thereafter wherever they land.

Our work was simple -- no big deal. We were doing our Matthew 25 duty: "I was thirsty and you gave me drink." But turns out, such work breaks U.S. laws, and to engage in it amounts to civil disobedience.

Authorities have periodically charged those who leave gallons of water in the desert with "littering" -- this, despite the fact that those who leave the water usually pick up far more empty bottles and debris. Christian authorities should commend them for following the example of Jesus. Civil authorities should commend them for beautifying the landscape.

But neither is the case, forcing our gesture into being a symbolic act -- and a politically charged one at that. Our trudging through the desert challenges the premise that these "illegals" have no business being in our backyard. Our taking effort and trouble proclaims the preciousness of their humanity. It says, despite our national crabbiness, we welcome them.

And like all good symbols, this one doesn't merely hang in the air like a mist. It is incarnate and real. The water gets drunk, bodies are replenished. The friends who do this humble work of mercy save real people who are desperate and dear. At nearly every stop, the gallons from the last drop were left there, empty.

So off we went, a kind of walking "Stations of the Cross." And along the way we came across the "illegals'" detritus -- empty soda bottles, shredded clothing, broken shoes, and one little girl's pink backpack, torn and threadbare from the unrelieved sun and the harsh terrain.

Our random discoveries added to the eerie feeling of being at the end of the world. In all directions, barrenness, hills of sand and rock, dusty dry shrubs, cacti of every description. And improbably, miles of yellow flowers. The desert in bloom -- an incongruity to my mind. I took it as a sign of welcome.

Preview NCR's Family Life Issue

Watch this video from NCR Editor Dennis Coday for highlights from our annual Family Life special section.

You won't find these articles on our website. Subscribe now to receive all the content from each biweekly issue.

The day was hot, the breeze gentle. And all told we walked for seven hours. Our muscles ached and our feet throbbed. Thirst heightened among our own little band. We were dry and tired. But we breathed a sigh of deep satisfaction; we had fulfilled our mission.

And we had managed a moment of solidarity with what our migrant sisters and brothers endure. Blisters and aching feet, sunburn and thirst and hunger, the risk of injury. What they bear alone, however, is the sheer terror of armed U.S. border police on the prowl, their adrenaline at an excited pitch in anticipation of making an arrest.

And more, they fear their paid "coyote," the man hired to lead them into the U.S., a corrupt man in some cases who extorts and threatens and, sometimes, rapes. Their life is in his hands and he knows it. If he has a mind to, he can oust them and turn back and leave them for dead. This happens all too often.

As we trundled along, toward the border we saw a U.S. helicopter hovering low. It is a tool of surveillance, to be sure, but also a weapon of sorts. There are frequent press reports of migrants who sustain injuries when helicopters swoop down on them, forcing them under the bushes.

Something of a panic follows. They stumble, split up, break apart -- one thinks of the infantile amusement of the pilot. And in scrambling, the group dissolves. Everyone thereafter must face the trackless terrain on his own, and often loses his way.

No other way to characterize it but that this is war against migrants. "Asymmetrical war" in the euphemism of the Defense Department, but war nonetheless. And in response a grass-roots human rights movement has arisen in Tucson: No More Deaths (www.nomoredeaths.org). Each summer they camp in the desert, leave water, search for the injured, and hold vigils for those in need. Their creative campaign is a whole new chapter in Gospel nonviolence and Gandhian satyagraha.

Our guides through the desert were my friends Leslie Klushmire of the "Rose in the Desert" Catholic Worker and Jim Marx from No More Deaths. Along the way they shared harrowing tales of some of the migrants they've met. They spoke, for example, of a young man they met recently who had made the journey, had no more money, and was asking directions for a town in Alabama, where he hoped to meet a relative. He thought it was just a few miles away.

On the day I was with them we met no one, which was a good sign -- it meant no one was desperate enough to come out of hiding for help.

When we visited the "No More Deaths" camp, in a very remote area, we gathered before a make-shift shrine for all the migrants who have died. The sight was heartbreaking. Near a cross lay dozens of children's shoes and backpacks, hairbrushes and women's clothes. Over the years, volunteers had picked up these last remains of life in the desert.

I am so grateful to these good folks who serve our migrant sisters and brothers and, through them, the suffering Christ. Their commitment reaches high and their compassion reaches deep, and they know their business. They say we need radical reform. We need more porous borders, new policies that keep families intact. They condemn our militarization of the border, our scape-goating, our selfishness and violence.

Homeland Security, they say, has near carte blanche to wage war on the poor. Meantime prison builders and equipment contractors grow richer. And politicians cast migrants as the enemy as a strategy for reelection. Migrants are not the enemy, say my friends. They are lovely people. And this new type of war is no mystery. It stems from our privilege in proximity to their extreme poverty. Indeed, the tide crossing our borders can be laid at the feet of NAFTA and corporate greed. Over and over, migrants tell the No More Death volunteers: "My children were always hungry."

We saw the hunger first hand in Nogales, Mexico, where we visited the Comedor, a soup kitchen and refugee center run by the Jesuits and the Missionary Sisters of the Eucharist. They serve two meals a day to the hundreds dumped into Mexico after the U.S. deports them. The work at the soup kitchen goes on non-stop; the deported slump in hunger and exhaustion, but leave grateful for the human exchange.

Sometimes, the government, spiteful and vindictive as it is, gambles with deportees' lives. Instances are known in which drivers transport them hundreds of miles to a different border section of Mexico, far from sustenance and help, often without identification. A kind of devious, wanton extra-judicial punishment. Meanwhile evidence mounts that so-called coyotes, running greater risks, are shaking down their clients, taking every penny, threatening them with injury and rape.

Add to this "Operation Streamline," a recently launched program that expedites convictions. After arrest, a migrant goes straight to a U.S. federal court, where about 70 migrants are convicted each hour. Due process has no place there. After repeated convictions, they go straight to prison, usually one owned by Corrections Corporation of America, a for-profit prison that issues stock and has shareholders. Such an arrangement, need it be added, makes a mockery of justice. Imprisonment of migrants serves economic interests. (On the other end are taxpayers. They pony up $11 million a month to incarcerate migrants and another $10 million a month for court costs.)

As I trudged in the heat, trying to take in the magnitude of the injustice made me dizzy. But when presently we headed down a stony hill into a hidden canyon my agitation settled and my thoughts coalesced. It was along this path, a few years back, that Josseline Hernandez Quinteros and her 10 year old brother, both from El Salvador, journeyed from El Salvador through Guatemala and Mexico in hopes of reaching their mother in California.

After scaling the border wall, Josseline grew sick. Stay here, the coyote told her, here on the path above the canyon. In a few days, he said, he would return for her. Some friends did return and found no sign of her. Two weeks later, Dan Millis, 28, a heroic volunteer from No More Deaths, found her dead by a small creek hidden at the bottom of the canyon. Her swollen feet rested in the water. Nearby on a rock sat her shoes. (See the new book for the full story: The Death of Josseline, by Margaret Regan, Beacon Press.)

Josseline, age 14, died alone in the desert.

My friends and I went to the spot where her body was found. And there we stood in silence, offering prayers for Josseline, for all the migrants, for the crucified of the U.S. war machine. "May no more children die," I prayed. "Not one more migrant, not one more sister or brother, not one more Josseline."

Calvary, I thought. Here is another Calvary, where the victims of imperial brutality die yet again. Fittingly, a nearby white cross stands as a memorial to Josseline, and a rebuke to the nation.

As for Dan Millis, two days after finding Josseline, he went back to work, this time at the Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge, southwest of Tucson. He carried with him gallons of water. Police arrested and ticketed him.

What to do? Certainly Gospel nonviolence calls us to enact a radical new immigration reform. A simple matter, really, a matter of compassion, social justice, and unconditional love. On its website, No More Deaths outlines some basic "Faith Based Principles for Immigration Reform." In part it reads:

  • First, recognize that the current militarized border enforcement strategy is an ill-conceived policy. Since 1998 more than 4000 migrants have died. These tragic and unnecessary deaths must stop….
  • Second, address the status of undocumented persons currently living in the US. Workers and their families currently living in the US must have access to a program of legalization that offers equity-building paths to permanent residency and eventual citizenships for workers and their families.
  • Third make family unity and reunification the cornerstone of the U.S. immigration system. Families must be allowed to legally and timely re-unify as well as to immigrate together as a unit.
  • Fourth, allow workers and their families to enter the U.S. to live and work in a safe, legal, orderly, and humane manner through an Employment-Focused immigration program.
  • Fifth, recognize that root causes of migration lie in environmental, economic, and trade inequities ...

We need radical immigration reform, indeed the disarmament of the country at every level. Walking those Stations of the Cross in the desert near Tucson makes that all too clear.

Our prayer: May Josseline be the last child to die, may we wake up to our responsibility. May we welcome everyone as sister and brother. May we seek God's borderless reign of peace with all our hearts, minds, and political will.

***

For further information, No More Deaths at www.nomoredeaths.org, and the Catholic Worker at www.roseofthedesert.org, also: www.Samaritanpatrol.org, www.humaneborders.org, www.borderlinks.org, www.derechoshumanoz.org, and the Catholic Campaign for Immigration Reform at www.justiceforimmigrants.org

****

To contribute to Catholic Relief Services' "Fr. John Dear Haiti Fund," go to: http://donate.crs.org/goto/fatherjohn. John will lead a retreat, "The Gospel According to John," April 30-May 2, near Stroudsburg, PA, see www.kirkridge.org; and "Gandhi, King, Day and Merton," at Ghost Ranch Center, Abiquiu, NM, see www.ghostranch.org. He will lead weekend retreats on "Jesus and the Gospel of peace" in Massachusetts, May 21-23 (see: www.rowecenter.org) and Los Angeles, June 17-20 (see: www.hsrcenter.com). John's latest book, Daniel Berrigan: Essential Writings (Orbis), along with other recent books, A Persistent Peace and Put Down Your Sword, as well as Patricia Normile's John Dear On Peace, are available from www.amazon.com. For further information, or to schedule a lecture, go to www.johndear.org

Dear Fr. John, I come right

Dear Fr. John,

I come right now from yet another huge funeral for a friend in our binational parish community ending at Sun-down in the graveyard in the desert by my home.

Please pray for us, as we with you always, that our merciful God continue to strengthen and to protect you, through the loving intercession of Our Lady of Guadalupe.

I read daily of these incidents here chronicled by Father John in the daily El Diario de juarez, the most informative newspaper I find in any language.

We also read of the Minutemen based in Arizona who had to officially "disband" because one of the founders was calling for everyone to come to the border, locked and loaded.

There are a whole lot of private citizens who claim to be ready to shoot anything that moves out in the desert there, and I am very glad you made it home safely, risking again courageously, incarnate, prophetically and selflessly arrest in the name of nonviolence, peace, justice and mercy, fulfilling, as you here indicate so well, our Gospel mandates.

I do regret it is now a year since we see anything from Dra. Clarissa Pinkola Estes, after her last April 28, 2009 article They Tried to Stop Her At The Border. This topic remains vital, and thank you once more for drawing it to our attention.

sincerely yours always,
frère charles du désert OSB OBLAT (Congrégation de Subiaco)

Pres Jimmy Carter was

Pres Jimmy Carter was sermonizing like yourself in the presence of a Chinese Government guest who asked how many Chinese he was willing to take of his hands? one million, five million, two hundred million? Pres. Carter suddenly became rational. How many would you and the Jesuits transport here and set up in your schools and country estates?. To be fair an equal number from Africa, India, (Catholic) Latin America would have to be included.
Did you ever think of a project to help people in their own country. You could preach responsible Government, family life, community minded honest business. The US Government would no doubt give you the money going to Homeland Security, Immigration Service, Law, Judicial and so on.

Your "Final Plan" is very

Your "Final Plan" is very misguided. In Point 1, for example, Dear explains how over 4000 migrants have died since 1998, therefore militarized border patrol strategy is “an ill-conceived policy.” However, the safety of the illegal immigrants is not the goal of these governmental organizations, so that point is moot; the strategy may be very well-conceived for its real purpose. America has neither the logistical nor the financial strength to undertake these programs (if indeed they are needed) outlined in points two, three, and four. While we can all agree that these things are fine in theory, it is in vain to expect them to be implemented by an indebted government embroiled in two wars and social changes for the country.

Fr John, - Do you think you

Fr John, - Do you think you can help the migrants without demonizing the DHS personnel out there doing their jobs? The American public has pretty much demanded what is going on out there. It's always the cop that gets blamed for the bad laws.

Past that - thanks to No More Deaths for all they do and to you for helping out.

Thank you John, for your

Thank you John, for your compassionate witness, and your prayers for the crucified innocents. My trip to Rafah Border made me think also about our own border with Mexico. Lord Jesus Christ, have mercy on us sinners.

What about Luke 10: What then

What about Luke 10: What then are we to do?

The film "The Year of Living Dangerously" depicts this dilemma very well ... who will be the Christ-figure to lead us at the border?

Fr. Dear: By enabling illegal

Fr. Dear: By enabling illegal immigrants, aren't you in danger of violating your Christian duty to obey the civil authorities, as St. Paul says we should do?

You might want to check out

You might want to check out some of Fr. Dear's actions and writings regarding the subject of obeying the civil authorities. If you go to his website, www.johndear.org, you can learn more about his perspective. By the way, St. Paul admonishes the Romans to submit to the authorites, not obey. If you enjoy reading theology, you might be interested in The Politics of Jesus by John Howard Yoder especially the chapter Let Every Soul Be Subject: Romans 13 and the
Authority of the State. You can find a simplified(and free) version of the book here. http://perthanabaptists.wordpress.com/politics-of-jesus-simplified/

Bless you Fr. John Dear for

Bless you Fr. John Dear for your passion and compassion regarding human rights and social justice.

Thank you for this article. I

Thank you for this article. I work with No More Deaths in the desert and at the comedor in Nogales, and I have seen first hand the atrocities of which you speak. More and more people are being picked up in raids in this country after having lived here as contributing members of society for sometimes decades. I have even met people who don't speak Spanish back in Mexico, as they came to this country when they were children. One young man was picked up and deported for jaywalking in Phoenix. He had been here since he was 3 and had graduated high school. He had never broken a law in his life. People say that the migrants should pursue a path to citizenship, but that (and even getting here legally) is a mind-blowingly complicated and expensive process, and far beyond the capabilities of most of the population who come here. I met a young man who only just became a citizen after 14 years of trying. And that was with parents who were relatively wealthy and knew all the ropes.

It is worth doing some research on the numbers, which are out there as a matter of public record, about the amount these people contribute to our society's coffers vs. the amount they "drain." That is always the battle cry of the anti-immigrant faction: that these people drain our resources. The numbers simply do not bear this out. An excellent book is Miguel de la Torre's "Trails of Hope and Terror." He has a lot of this information in the book, but it can be gotten online as well. It would be good for all of us to have numbers in our heads to counteract the numbers that the ragers and the angry throw out with such reckless abandon.

Paz a todos.

http://www.renewamerica.com/c

http://www.renewamerica.com/columns/abbott/100506

From Philip C. Onochié:

I have been following the illegal immigration problem for quite some time. It is a sad state of affairs when the USCCB conflicts with the Catechism of the Catholic Church — that's always the case when it comes to immigration and health care. I recently took it upon myself to read the CCC and was astounded to see how straightforward the language in it is:

2241 The more prosperous nations are obliged, to the extent they are able, to welcome the foreigner in search of the security and the means of livelihood which he cannot find in his country of origin. Public authorities should see to it that the natural right is respected that places a guest under the protection of those who receive him.

Political authorities, for the sake of the common good for which they are responsible, may make the exercise of the right to immigrate subject to various juridical conditions, especially with regard to the immigrants' duties toward their country of adoption. Immigrants are obliged to respect with gratitude the material and spiritual heritage of the country that receives them, to obey its laws and to assist in carrying civic burdens.

How our dear bishops draw the conclusion that the above citing commends us to protect illegal aliens who break the law to come into the country is beyond me. When a state is truly burdened by an overflow of people so much so that crime is up and resources to take care of this problem are down, what is the state to do except start cracking down on people who use state services without the ability to pay for it through taxes?

The good bishops have also mentioned one part of the problem. Of course we want to treat people with dignity. But arresting people for breaking the law is not wrong; neither is arresting people for traffic violations and other law infractions, which is what the new law allows enforcers of the law to do.

Make no mistake: This(Arizona) law is basically the same law we have on the federal level. The governor appealed to the regime to help with their problem, but was ignored. She acted well and cautiously, too, so that this law would not give her police force unreasonable power. To fix this problem, perhaps we ought to figure out the tax situation when immigration policies are on the table. We need to move toward removing the federal and state taxes and employing only sales taxes that will provide revenue for the states. That way, we can support our local officials with the means to do their jobs while we protect our states more from a surge of lawbreakers.

Our bishops need to speak to the ordinaries around the borders in Mexico. A message of greed, corruption and stewardship needs to be heard by all. Their faithful need to be told and encouraged to live within and under the law, rather than above it. Where is the accountability there? Why do our bishops always put the government in charge of taking care of us when it is their job to catechize us? People who come here illegally leave their families broken or put the lives of their families in danger by crossing illegally — all for what? With nobody to take care of them, do they resort to begging or stealing? I don't know.

What I do know is that if there is a chance for me to put my family in danger by crossing illegally, I will not. I am more sympathetic to Cuba for the fact that they are really oppressed, but to come here only to live on the streets or on the run is no way to dignify yourself.

I am a legal immigrant. I know of pain and stress. There is pain and suffering going through the process, but all I suffered was not in vain. I put in my time and I spent the money, but in the end, it was worth it to be able to live in peace. The bottom line is, I am tired of reading columns or articles by the USCCB or the likes (Archbishop Dolan) within the Church who support illegals without seeing the CCC being quoted.

This is known that cash can

This is known that cash can make us free. But how to act if someone does not have money? The one way is to receive the home loans and just secured loan.

In the writing services it is

In the writing services it is easy to look for some information and essay writing referring to this topic . To make much easier your scholar career buy essays and use your rest time!

Scholars have got now good

Scholars have got now good Internet sources to purchase the dissertation work and just imazing article close to this post at the trustworthy dissertation service.

Thanks so much for the good

Thanks so much for the good release just about this topic. I couldn’t find this kind of dissertation thesis in web and was going to buy the thesis writing. But, I have all needed stuff at present time.

it is not limited to float in

it is not limited to float in the air like a fog. That is embodied and real. The water is drunk, the bodies are replenished. The friends you make this humble work of mercy to save real people who are desperate and wanted. At almost every stop, gallons of the last drop stood there, empty.
http://jogosdecarros9.org

There is pain and suffering

There is pain and suffering going through the process, but all I suffered was not in vain. I put in my time and I spent the money, but in the end, it was worth it to be able to live in peace.http://juegosdebobesponja2.org

Post new comment

NCR Comment code:

  1. Be respectful. Do not attack the writer. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  2. Use appropriate language. Avoid vulgarities and slurs.
  3. Keep to the point. Deliberate digressions don't aid the discussion.

For more detailed guidelines, visit our User Guidelines page.

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
(if you have one; if not, leave this blank)
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <font> <swf> <swf list>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may use <swf file="song.mp3"> to display Flash files inline

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This is to prove you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.