Spiritual, but not religious

There are probably hundreds and hundreds of thousands around the country now who make some deliberate effort to live simply.

-- Myra and John live in the suburbs of Chicago and keep plastic bins in their garage for recyclables. They spend a few minutes each day sorting and separating, then an hour a month taking the bins to drop-off centers. Both also choose to ride public transportation to their jobs weekdays rather than driving. When they recently bought a new car, they opted for a hybrid. The whole family chooses to eat a bit lower on the food chain than is widely done, limiting their meat consumption. They also limit the amount of time they watch tv, choosing to read to and talk with their children most evenings.

-- In rural New Mexico, Cyril and Ed card the wool and spin yarn from a dozen sheep they raise in their four-acre back yard. They also keep goats for milk and make their own cheese when they have time. Both are self-employed computer programmers and work as consultants out of their home, a sprawling adobe structure they built themselves. When they must travel to faraway cities on business, they take the train.

-- Marie is an accountant who lives in Kansas City. She lives alone in an elegant apartment. She spends a good deal of her time exploring her inner life, through journaling, keeping track of her dreams, spiritual reading and long walks with friends. What’s left of her time is spent in vigorous volunteer work, helping maintain a women’s spirituality center and keeping the financial records for a local food cooperative.

-- In southeastern Kansas, Eleanor and Robert alternate between living a year of two in their small town community with a year or two in ministry. Eleanor works as an administrator at the local college, while Robert serves as a minister in the local Mennonite church. A year ago they finished a stint as teachers in the Navajo lands of northern Arizona. They buy their clothes at thrift stores. Robert bicycles every day to his church office.

-- In Portland, Oregon, Marcus and Linda are forty-something who above all love travel and adventure. They work for several years (he as a teacher; she as a nurse) until they’ve earned enough to coast for a while then quit their jobs to spend six or eight months traveling the world. Recently they toured Indonesia, Malaysia and other countries in southeast Asia. The mid-1990s found them living for a year in Costa Rica.

-- Vickie deliberately chooses not to have an income level high enough to require her to pay federal taxes, because 50 to 60 percent goes to pay for war – past, present and future. She earns some money from painting houses and doing substitute teaching. She spends her time working as a community organizer and refurbishing her old three-story house in the inner city.

NCR: February 3-16, 2012

Subscribe to NCR to get all the news and special features that aren't always available online. In this issue:

- US News: Bishops Host Conference on Immigration
Conference fields advocates' questions on law, policy

- Special Section:Deacons.Serving as parish administrator; roles of wives; and more

- Study: Black Catholics are more engaged
New study by Notre Dame researcher about parish involvement in America

Subscribe now!

-- Beth and Mary subsist almost entirely on organically grown vegetables, poultry and cheese, which they purchase in bulk quantities from a cooperative food-buying club. They live in a roomy dome-shaped house standing on bottomland Mary inherited 20 years ago in the Missouri Ozarks. They make their living weaving rope sandals and hammocks and selling their goods at craft fairs. Both also play hand-made musical instruments in a local bluegrass band.

Generosity and responsibility have taken root in these people’s lives. The need to celebrate and enjoy life’s best gifts has a high priority. Some commit themselves for overtly religious or spiritual reasons. Others make the attempt out of concern for the environment or compassion for the other life with which we share the planet. Still others swim against the tide of our culture and society because they simply cannot abide employment in a full-time job or working for someone else or the stressful rigors and heartless oppressions of the system. Many just want to free up lots of time, to live in an uncluttered way, in order to devote themselves to their enthusiasms and loves.

Most can probably explain forthrightly their motivation for undertaking these endeavors of simple living – and these reasons vary as widely as do the life experiences, personalities, philosophies, politics, and creativity of the people themselves. In fact, a book of in-depth interviews with a dozen people who attempt to live simply would make for interesting reading.

Whatever the reasons for practicing simple living, the daily choices, prioritizing, and wider decisions that must be made – the conscious “life-style” involved – embody, I believe, a practical description of some spiritual condition. The consciously simple lifestyle is an outward reflection of some developed and developing inner reality.

Quite often, it’s what is meant by the clichéd declaration: “I’m spiritual but not religious.”

I am not sure I would say

I am not sure I would say that these people are living simply, though they are certainly living differently. With the exception of the first example, there is no mention of children. Could it be that being childless makes it possible to pursue different ways of living? Though I think it does, I also think there is no substitute for the rewards of parenting and the engagement with the world that results from it.

I think the LCWR says that it

I think the LCWR says that it is spiritual but not religious.

Satan is spiritual and not

Satan is spiritual and not religious, too.

Thanks for the examples of

Thanks for the examples of life truly lived.

If, after two thousand years

If, after two thousand years of the rich Catholic spiritual tradition, "spirituality" is reduced to such puff--separating garbage, riding the bike, weaving rope--then are in bad straits. Nothing personal, but spirituality as a Christian understands it has more depth, heft, and substance, than separating your brown and green glass.

I'm sorry to see some

I'm sorry to see some negative comments about simply living.

Living simply does not mean living simple-mindedly. Spirituality is not boiled down to separating garbage. The simple living lifestyle is one that embraces living in the moment, honoring each moment and God's presence in each moment. It's not about rules and regulations or trying to convince anyone else of anything. It's simply reflecting on the most important aspects of life and making choices and decisions based upon whether or not they reflect those aspects that are precious.

I have known life fully within the Church, and I have experienced this lifestyle of simple living. I know that both can be spiritually nourishing.

There are many ways to experience God and spirituality, and it is not honoring of God or our brothers and sisters in faith to demean their way of communing with God. There is more to it than what is presented in the article, well written as it is. One should not judge others' spirituality without first trying to experience it.

Spirituality cannot be handled in a one-size-fits-all way. Even throughout a single lifetime, spiritual needs change. There are times when the Church seems cold, distant, and a too human institution. Perhaps in these times, finding God in a more intimate way, through living simply and focusing on daily blessings is not something He would reject.

In my own experience, simple living is a way of life that has come to me as I have grown and matured. When I was younger, less mature, I would not have understood it. I'm not so sure I wouldn't have seen it as spirituality boiled down to sorting the garbage.

But it really is much, much more than that. For me, it has proven to be nothing less than finding peace--time and space to be with God.

Post new comment

NCR Comment code:

  1. Be respectful. Do not attack the writer. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  2. Use appropriate language. Avoid vulgarities and slurs.
  3. Keep to the point. Deliberate digressions don't aid the discussion.

For more detailed guidelines, visit our User Guidelines page.

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
(if you have one; if not, leave this blank)
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <font> <swf> <swf list>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may use <swf file="song.mp3"> to display Flash files inline

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This is to prove you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.