Pope pushes Obama envoy on abortion, conscience protections

Rome -- Miguel Diaz presented his credentials to Pope Benedict XVI this morning as President Barack Obama's ambassador to the Holy See, and the new envoy drew a pledge of cooperation on international issues from the pope, as well as clear insistence upon "the inalienable right to life from the moment of conception to natural death," as well as "the right to conscientious object on the part of health care workers, and indeed all citizens."

Both abortion and the rights of conscience are important issues in the health care reform debate currently underway in the United States. Obama has pledged to make any reform package "abortion neutral," but the Catholic bishops in the United States say that so far, none of the existing proposals meet that standard.

In more general terms, Benedict XVI said he looks forward to "fruitful dialogue and cooperation in the promotion of human dignity, respect for fundamental human rights, and the service of justice, solidarity and peace within the whole human family."

Diaz was nominated by Obama on June 18, confirmed by the U.S. Senate on August 4, and sworn in on August 21. A professor of theology at the University of St. John’s and the College of St. Benedict in Minnesota, Diaz is the first Hispanic to hold the ambassador’s position.

The full text of Benedict's remarks to Diaz this morning follows.

The full text of Diaz's remarks are here: Presentation of Credentials Miguel H. Diaz Ambassador of the United States to the Holy See

* * *
Your Excellency,

I am pleased to accept the Letters by which you are accredited Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of the United States of America. I recall with pleasure my meeting with President Barack Obama and his family last July, and willingly reciprocate the kind greetings which you bring from him. I also take this occasion to express my confidence that diplomatic relations between the United States and the Holy See, formally initiated twenty-five years ago, will continue to be marked by fruitful dialogue and cooperation in the promotion of human dignity, respect for fundamental human rights, and the service of justice, solidarity and peace within the whole human family.

In the course of my Pastoral Visit to your country last year I was pleased to encounter a vibrant democracy, committed to the service of the common good and shaped by a vision of equality and equal opportunity based on the God-given dignity and freedom of each human being. That vision, enshrined in the nation’s founding documents, continues to inspire the growth of the United States as a cohesive yet pluralistic society constantly enriched by the gifts brought by new generations, including the many immigrants who continue to enhance and rejuvenate American society. In recent months, the reaffirmation of this dialectic of tradition and originality, unity and diversity has recaptured the imagination of the world, many of whose peoples look to the American experience and its founding vision in their own search for viable models of accountable democracy and sound development in an increasingly interdependent and global society.

NCR: February 3-16, 2012

Subscribe to NCR to get all the news and special features that aren't always available online. In this issue:

- US News: Bishops Host Conference on Immigration
Conference fields advocates' questions on law, policy

- Special Section: Deacons. Serving as parish administrator; roles of wives; and more

- Study: Black Catholics are more engaged
New study by Notre Dame researcher about parish involvement in America

Subscribe now!

For this reason, I appreciate your acknowledgement of the need for a greater spirit of solidarity and multilateral engagement in approaching the urgent problems facing our planet. The cultivation of the values of "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness" can no longer be seen in predominantly individualistic or even national terms, but must rather be viewed from the higher perspective of the common good of the whole human family. The continuing international economic crisis clearly calls for a revision of present political, economic and financial structures in the light of the ethical imperative of ensuring the integral development of all people. What is needed, in effect, is a model of globalization inspired by an authentic humanism, in which the world’s peoples are seen not merely as neighbors but as brothers and sisters.

Multilateralism, for its part, should not be restricted to purely economic and political questions; rather, it should find expression in a resolve to address the whole spectrum of issues linked to the future of humanity and the promotion of human dignity, including secure access to food and water, basic health care, just policies governing commerce and immigration, particularly where families are concerned, climate control and care for the environment, and the elimination of the scourge of nuclear weapons. With regard to the latter issue, I wish to express my satisfaction for the recent Meeting of the United Nations Security Council chaired by President Obama, which unanimously approved the resolution on atomic disarmament and set before the international community the goal of a world free of nuclear weapons. This is a promising sign on the eve of the Review Conference of the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons.

Genuine progress, as the Church’s social teaching insists, must be integral and humane; it cannot prescind from the truth about human beings and must always be directed to their authentic good. In a word, fidelity to man requires fidelity to the truth, which alone is the guarantee of freedom and real development. For her part the Church in the United States wishes to contribute to the discussion of the weighty ethical and social questions shaping America’s future by proposing respectful and reasonable arguments grounded in the natural law and confirmed by the perspective of faith. Religious vision and religious imagination do not straiten but enrich political and ethical discourse, and the religions, precisely because they deal with the ultimate destiny of every man and woman, are called to be a prophetic force for human liberation and development throughout the world, particularly in areas torn by hostility and conflict. In my recent visit to the Holy Land I stressed the value of understanding and cooperation among the followers of the various religions in the service of peace, and so I note with appreciation your government’s desire to promote such cooperation as part of a broader dialogue between cultures and peoples.

Allow me, Mr. Ambassador, to reaffirm a conviction which I expressed at the outset of my Apostolic Journey to the United States. Freedom – the freedom which Americans rightly hold dear – "is not only a gift but also a summons to personal responsibility;" it is "a challenge held out to each generation, and it must constantly be won over to the cause of good" (Address at the White House, 16 April 2008). The preservation of freedom is inseparably linked to respect for truth and the pursuit of authentic human flourishing. The crisis of our modern democracies calls for a renewed commitment to reasoned dialogue in the discernment of wise and just policies respectful of human nature and human dignity. The Church in the United States contributes to this discernment particularly through the formation of consciences and her educational apostolate, by which she makes a significant and positive contribution to American civic life and public discourse. Here I think particularly of the need for a clear discernment with regard to issues touching the protection of human dignity and respect for the inalienable right to life from the moment of conception to natural death, as well as the protection of the right to conscientious objection on the part of health care workers, and indeed all citizens. The Church insists on the unbreakable link between an ethics of life and every other aspect of social ethics, for she is convinced that, in the prophetic words of the late Pope John Paul II, "a society lacks solid foundations when, on the one hand, it asserts values such as the dignity of the person, justice and peace, but then, on the other hand, radically acts to the contrary by allowing or tolerating a variety of ways in which human life is devalued and violated, especially where it is weak or marginalized" (Evangelium Vitae, 93; cf. Caritas in Veritate, 15).

Mr. Ambassador, as you undertake your new mission in the service of your country I offer you my good wishes and the promise of my prayers. Be assured that you may always count on the offices of the Holy See to assist and support you in the fulfillment of your duties. Upon you and your family, and upon all the beloved American people, I cordially invoke God’s blessings of wisdom, strength and peace.

Mr. Diaz, impossibly,

Mr. Diaz, impossibly, "serves" both the Pharaoh and "The Church"?

Is that "natural death" with

Is that "natural death" with or without healthcare?

If one is in prison they get

If one is in prison they get healthcare no matter what the crime. Where is the justice in that?

Thanks, Yr Holiness... now,

Thanks, Yr Holiness... now, let's hear about Life 'After' birth ... Howabout speaking out on behalf of those who thousands who die due to lack of access to healthcare?

What lack of access to

What lack of access to heathcare? There are laws on the books now. If you show up at the hospital they can not refuse heathcare.. Just ask 17 million illegal aliens.. Go to our hospitals and look...This part of the built in cost of our heathcare now and it will only get worse with socialising it.

As you know full Well, in the

As you know full Well, in the U.S. no one dies because they are denied adequate, even exceptional, health care. The uninsured have immediate access to all emergency rooms, ambulance service and are treated exactly like those with health insurance. And in the major cities at least there are free health clinics. I know of several in KC,Ks and KC,Mo. Of course the hospitals and clinics will try to collect from all who are not insured but whom they have treated. You should also be aware that most of those who have no insurance can afford it but simply choose not to buy it. The data is out there so don't try your propaganda here. And of course you know that the Pope is concerned about adequate health care for all but believes, correctly, that it is neither the duty no the responsibility of the State to furnish health care except for the truely indigent. And in America, the indigent are cared for.

RE: dennis d & Tgray –

RE: dennis d & Tgray – healthcare
I offer the following:
1. Para.4, includes “..., basic health care, ..”
2. “life from the moment of conception to natural death," includes the short span in between, or “life ‘After’ birth”.
3. Para. 5, states the “the Church’s social teaching insist, …”. And, provides sound and forceful argument “For … the Church in the US …to contribute to the … weighty ethical and social questions shaping America…” In other word, “Sir, please tell your president, legislators, and judiciary
4. Para. 6, PBXVI states his “conviction”, and reissues his “challenge” of “personal responsibility (accountability)”, where health care is specifically targeted in addressing the “inseparable” and “unbreakable” link between true justice and “social ethics” and the moral conscience of health care workers.
(Emphasis mine)

I believe his eminence Pope Benedict was most gracious in accepting the US Ambassador, and most diplomatic in stating the Church’s position on both global and US-specific topics.
On my reading, I came away with the following, concise, interpretation of the text:
Or, in other word, “Sir, in all charity, please take back the message to those that sent and confirmed you (including your judiciary), that, I, the undeserved servant of the servants of God, in communion with the USCCB, and the universal Church, do humbly assert the inalienable right to interject ourselves into global (US or otherwise) discourse, including politics, in the aforesaid areas, and most specifically in the area of “social ethics” and health care legislation which you are currently debating, regarding passive assignation to abortion and euthanasia, and the moral conscience of the health care worker; and please, make no mistake about it, I do not deviate from the dictates of JPII, we are the Church united, and by command and authority of our founder, our Lord Jesus, the Christ, guided by the Holy Ghost, and, in the name of the Almighty, we must, and we shall! To do otherwise is to deny your very existence. And, let all God’s people say, Amen. Now, go in peace my son."

Kind regards,
MAO

Our current Pope is great.

Our current Pope is great. Like a good father he knows how to highlight the good and at the same time thoughtfully challenge. May our country and political leaders be open to his call for a culture of life and love where the most vulnerable among us are welcomed in life and protected in law.

The Catholic Church is never

The Catholic Church is never going to get anywhere in its fight for the freedom of life for the yet to be pushed out of the womb babies! Not untill it get up enough courage to call Abortion what it really is: The cold blooded premediated murder of totally innocent babies. We 'Kill' chickens! That is not a very serious thing to do. We are not being very honest when we substitute "Kill" for a very truthful and accurate word of what is really happening to these little babies. But this letter will never be seem for the church (as it is run by it's leader today) will not allow the 'M' word to be uttered and those few who dare are soon blacklisted. I can't believe I wasted my time writting this - my words must be hungry for the waste paper basket! Nevertheless!! Know you all that one man tried to stand up and tell the whole truth - the telling of which is the only thing that has chance of saving those babies who are even now slated to be murdered in cold blood! "ABORTION IS MURDER!" AND, IN GENERAL, MORE THAN ANYTHING ELSE IN THE WORLD, IT IS DEFINITELY THAT! - BUT SO FEW CATHOLIC KNOW THAT AND YOU KNOW WHY!

If only you had written your

If only you had written your diatribe sooner, just think how many fewer abortions there would have been. What took you so long?

When will people stop

When will people stop screaming that the rest of us don't know abortion is murder. Your shreaking will not stop it. Barak Obama does not alone make our laws. Tragically we have members of Congress and the Supreme Court that don't see abortion this way. Many many of us with great determination speak to people about this every day and try not to be strident or judgmental. You can quietly and mercifully talk to someone about this and save a life. One man yelling and condemning speaks out, OK, it's your way. Many, every day, hold and comfort someone in distress and plead for the babies and are successful.

The title of this piece is

The title of this piece is totally inaccurate when looking at the specific words of Pope Benedict, "Here I think particularly of the need for a clear discernment with regard to issues touching the protection of human dignity and respect for the inalienable right to life from the moment of conception to natural death, as well as the protection of the right to conscientious objection on the part of health care workers, and indeed all citizens." At no time could I see him pushing the Obama envoy on abortion, or conscience protections--he simply reiterated how important it is to hold what Obama has already spoken. All people with tender consciences will respect all life from beginning to end--not just one end.

The headline is very misleading. All of us must read critically, making sure we understand what we see and what we hear. Misleading headlines only help to pit one side against another. In our fractured world, we don't need anything to pit us one against another--for the sake of our world, we need to listen to each other with respect even though we don't agree. If we cannot do that, we are not even following the teachings of Jesus in scripture, and certainly not the Social Justice Teachings of the Church of which the first is respect for individuals (Called Human Dignity). How can we help each other to get to heaven when we keep condemning each other here on earth?

Ambassador Diaz brilliantly

Ambassador Diaz brilliantly worded letter to His Holiness is a golden bridge needed to improve communication between Rome and Washington. Genesis 11/1-7 defines problems that must be resolved better sooner than later. Let us include President Obama's envoy and his family in our prayers.

The Obama-backed House

The Obama-backed House Democratic Health Care bill, HR 3200, which has already been favorably reported out of three committees, would slash spending for Medicare by more than $500 Billion, ration treatments for everyone, encourage euthanasia for the elderly, and provide federal funding of elective abortions.

For more information, see http://www.my60secondscoops.com/publications/id.185/pub_detail.asp

"My 60-Second Scoops is a

"My 60-Second Scoops is a free newsletter service provided by American Target Advertising, Inc. (ATA), and ConservativeHQ.com (CHQ), for people who have responded to appeals from its political and charitable clients."

That aside, Art Kelly, is the solution to go along with all of this, if it is more than alarmism intended to get attention for the purposes of advertising and fundraising?

I think the solution is to expand Medicare so that everyone can get the medical care they need by contributing a percentage of their income -- instead of buying an fixed price insurance policy which can amount to a huge percentage of income depending on little one earns and which does not even cover most preventive care and which sets upper limits on what it will pay.

This way, there would be more money coming into Medicare to cover the costs of those whose medical care costs the most, while the new members would be spending less of their income than they do now for all their combined medical care costs and getting more for their money than they do now.

Look at it this way, I now contribute 1% of my household income to your medical care, while I contribute over 3% to my family's medical care. I would like to contribute 1% instead of over 3% and get the care you get.

Good grief!!! We're wasting

Good grief!!! We're wasting our time on Rome!!

Post new comment

NCR Comment code:

  1. Be respectful. Do not attack the writer. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  2. Use appropriate language. Avoid vulgarities and slurs.
  3. Keep to the point. Deliberate digressions don't aid the discussion.

For more detailed guidelines, visit our User Guidelines page.

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
(if you have one; if not, leave this blank)
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <font> <swf> <swf list>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may use <swf file="song.mp3"> to display Flash files inline

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This is to prove you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.