NCR on Kindle - NCR classifieds - YouTube - Twitter - Facebook - Email Alerts - RSS
Abp Dolan on Economic Crisis
I have just received a copy of a letter (text below) sent by Archbishop Timothy Dolan, President of the USCCB, to all of the bishops in the U.S. that calls their attention to the newly released census data on poverty. Archbishop Dolan writes that the numbers are so shocking that the Administrative Committee wanted to do more than simply issue a statement, and decided that a direct, and specific call from Dolan to his brother bishops might better galvanize bishops, priests and laity to demand that our political and economic leaders address these issues of poverty.
It is heartening to see the USCCB recognize that the Church's stance on poverty is every bit as critical as its stance on other issues. And, it is very encouraging to see Archbishop Dolan writing with such passion about this issue.
Here is the full text of the letter:
September 15, 2011
Dear Brother Bishops,
The Administrative Committee urged me to write you on an important matter for our Church and nation. During our recent meeting, it was reported that 46 million people (15%) now live in poverty in the United States. This report follows dismal unemployment figures in recent months. For us as bishops, these numbers are not statistics, but people suffering and wounded in their human dignity. They are parents who cannot feed their children, families that have lost their homes and jobless workers who have lost not only income, but also a sense of their place in society. For us, each of these persons is a child of God with innate human dignity and rights that deserve respect. These numbers bring home to us the human costs and moral consequences of a broken economy that cannot fully utilize the talents, energy and work of all our people. We know the terrible toll the current economic turmoil is taking on families and communities. In our own Catholic dioceses we are struggling to match scarce resources with growing needs and have had to make very difficult financial, personnel and organizational choices.
We discussed how best to respond to this urgent pastoral challenge. The Administrative Committee wanted something more than a public statement. Instead, they asked me to write to all the bishops and ask you to continue do all you can to lift up the human, moral and spiritual dimensions of the ongoing economic crisis. Widespread unemployment, underemployment and pervasive poverty are diminishing human lives, undermining human dignity, and hurting children and families. I hope we can use our opportunities as pastors, teachers, and leaders to focus public attention and priority on the scandal of so much poverty and so many without work in our society. In order to assist you in these ongoing efforts, the Administrative Committee has asked the bishops' conference to provide you, diocesan staffs and other leaders with resources and materials for preaching, educating the faithful and advocating on behalf of the poor and jobless. You can already find some materials that can be helpful in these tasks on the "Unemployment and Poverty" page of the USCCB website. This page will be updated periodically and additional resources will be available shortly. Please share with the bishops' conference your own statements, resources or actions that you have taken to address these issues (please email or fax to 202-541-3339).
The best way out of poverty is to work at a living wage. In the words of Pope Benedict XVI, 'Being out of work or dependent on public or private assistance for a prolonged period undermines the freedom and creativity of the person and his family and social relationships, causing great psychological and spiritual suffering' (Caritas in Veritate, no. 25). The common good will not advance; economic security will not be achieved; and individual initiative will be weakened when so many live without the dignity of work and bear the crushing burden of poverty. These economic failures have fundamental institutional and systemic elements that have either been ignored or made worse by political and economic behaviors, which have undermined trust and confidence. However, this is not time to make excuses or place blame. It is a time for everyone to accept their own personal and institutional responsibility to help create jobs and to overcome poverty, each in accord with their own abilities and opportunities. Individuals and families, faith-based and community groups, businesses and labor, government at every level, all must work together and find effective ways to promote the common good in national and economic life.
Sixteen million of our children (almost one out of four) are growing up poor. It is especially disheartening that African-Americans and Hispanics live with unemployment and poverty at far higher rates than others. Immigrant workers are especially vulnerable to exploitation and unfair treatment. These realities contradict our national pledge of "liberty and justice for all." They also contradict the consistent teaching of our Church. Our Catholic tradition begins with respect for the life and dignity of all, requires a priority concern for poor and vulnerable people, reflects the ties and bonds of solidarity, respects the mutual relationships of subsidiarity, and promotes the dignity of work and protection for workers.
As bishops, we lead communities that include many of those who lack sufficient work or resources to live a decent life. Every day, we serve 'the least of these' in our midst. In our Catholic parishes, schools, charities, hospitals and other ministries, the poor, the underemployed and the unemployed are not issues, but people with names and faces. It is an essential part of our work as Catholics to build a more just society and economy. We feed the hungry, shelter the homeless, educate the young, welcome refugees and care for the sick and vulnerable. Our Church serves and stands in solidarity with those who are poor and jobless, helping them break the cycle of poverty and act on behalf of their own families and communities. Our Conference will continue to urge our leaders to assist and protect the poor and jobless as they seek to promote economic growth and fiscal responsibility. The Catholic community will strengthen our work with others to address the economic, family, social and other factors which contribute to widespread poverty.
In these tough economic times, we turn to the God who loves us. We pray for those who need work. We lift up the poor and suffering. We ask God's guidance for our nation. This is not a time to give into discouragement. It is a time for faith, hope and love. Faith offers us moral principles to guide us in the days ahead. Christian hope gives us strength. Christ's love calls us to care for those left behind in this broken economy.
Thank you my brothers for your pastoral leadership in preaching the Gospel and standing strong for the Church's moral and social teaching in these difficult days.
Most Reverend Timothy M. Dolan
Archbishop of New York
President, United States Conference of Catholic Bishops






Where have ABP Dolan and his
Where have ABP Dolan and his brother bishops been for the past several months while this issue has been playig out in Cogress? I notice it didn't take them long to respond to the HHS proposed regulations regarding the availability of contraceptives to all women. There was an insert in our parish bulletin yesterday from the USCCB urging us to comment to HHS on these regulations. I sent a comment to HHS, but I don't think it was one the bishops would like.
Rosemary Insidioso
Bangor, Michigan
A letter that essentially
A letter that essentially says NOTHING.
"The best way out of poverty
"The best way out of poverty is to work at a living wage."
Maybe the Church should start with itself and start paying most of its employees a 'living wage'?
I hope Archbishop Dolan will
I hope Archbishop Dolan will send a copy of his letter to every Catholic
member of the Congress. Especially, I would like a copy sent to House Speaker
John Boehner.
The standard statement for
The standard statement for written exclamation these days is OMG! If anything deserves the appelation it's this statement written by the President of the USCCB. Given so much that's gone over the dam these past couple of years to read such a strong plea in favor of the poor and vulnerable is refreshing to say the least. Why did it have to take the fact of 15+% of people known to be in poverty (that's almost one out of every six persons and one out of almost every four children)before a priority would be urged?
The solution, however, isn't charity nor jobs w/living wage alone. Pastoral work implies that efforts must be made in the political sectors of universal health care as well. I, for one, hope to see the unified force of USCCB (as well as my local Ordinary)behind all these social issues.
Has Dolan seen any
Has Dolan seen any relationship between the political positions he's taken on the bishops' behalf and the poverty that has increased as a result? Just one example: without judicious and conscientious use of contraception, the economic strain on a family grows with each child added -- and that's assuming the children are healthy.
There's a price to be paid for siding with the "I've got mine; too bad about you and yours" Republicans. Oh, well -- guess they're fine with that as long as the zygotes are protected. After they're born? Not the Republicans' problem. And not the problem of the bishops who have done their best to put Republicans into power and keep them there.
Susan Lersch
susan.lersch@yahoo.com
The letter will make zero
The letter will make zero impact on the GOP legislators in Congress, including the many Catholic GOPs. Their first priority is to protect "job creators," code for anyone who makes over $200,000 per year (most of whom create no jobs), not the poor or disabled or others who make less.
It is too late for their
It is too late for their credibility. They backed the wrong horse. Even when they get to the urgency elements at the very end, they say that it is a time for faith, hope, and love. It is also a time for anger. I don't hear a whimper of anger. We are not to point fingers or assign blame. Why not? They talk about institutional and systemic failures, but not of greed and theft. They are using an inappropriate vocabulary. In the Bishops letter to Congress there was no mention of the wealthy, only of the poor. The rich have been growing richer by transferring wealth to themselves. The Church is too aligned with the rich and powerful and safe and is not connected to the margins. Too bad; so sad. Jesus is very disappointed in his shepherds. Do you think they will show up at any of the planned marches? The letter spoke of giving feedback to the USCCB regarding "actions" taken. Perhaps we could post here about actions planned so that the Bishops could join... There is a march on September 30th in Boston. Event will start sometime around 2:45/3pm at Boston Common. Consider that an invitation to the Archbishop of Boston and clergy. It is the feast of St. Jerome, who in addition to being a Scripture scholar, had a very strong temper. "He was, as someone has said, no admirer of moderation whether in virtue or against evil." http://www.americancatholic.org/Features/Saints/saint.aspx?id=1154 A good patron for the day.
If the Bishops are truly
If the Bishops are truly concerned about the poor, they need to stop being so myopic about the definition of pro-life. Their current "one trick pony" attitude only gives juice to politicians who give lip service to being anti-abortion [and have done almost nothing once elected], but care little for the children of the poor once they are born.
Take the blinders off, guys.
I wonder what the Bishops
I wonder what the Bishops have SAID and DONE about the States Cutting Jobs, Benefits, and Services? As noted elswhere in the Nationa Catholic Reporter, there has been nothing from the bishops about cutting the unions in Wisconsin, Ohio and other states.
What about living wages for employees of the Catholic Church and Schools?
"Take the blinders off,
"Take the blinders off, guys."
I am unfailingly surprised by the caustic bitterness of those who post in the NCR comboxes. Here is MSW, who unfailingly posts interesting, thoughtful observations on the state of affairs theological and political, and does so with panache and (for the most part) good grace. Then I get to the combox, and it's never anything but unhinged loathing and vituperation. What a disparity! MSW's posts deserve to be part of a real conversation, not a complainers' circle.
Of course the poverty problem
Of course the poverty problem is bad and getting worse. But it is not only politicans who need to pay attention but also the church.
In my diocese ( Phoenix Arixona ) the bishop sent fifty thousand dollars to Maine in order to defeat a same sex marriage referendum.
Where does he get an extra fifty thousnds dollars and how can he send it with no input from the diocesan boards when his own office says that people are hungry in the diocese.
The diocese keeps asking for money for the poor as they make plans for a new cathedral. I guess the old cathedral won't do.
What would fifty thousand dollars do for hungry families? or how many families could you put in apartments for awhile with that sort of money.
The clergy has got to get over the idea that the people in the pews have no say in how the money they get is spent.
I know that is a radical notion but it is way past time for it to happen.
Post new comment