Wanted: women of spirit in our own time

Aug. 11, 2010
Sr. Joan Chittister

The Leadership Conference of Women Religious is meeting in Dallas this week under scrutiny from Rome and with a cloud hanging over its head.

What shall we think about such a time as this when the women religious who have built, carried, led and staffed every work of the church from the earliest days of this nation to this present time of turbulence and transition are being accused of being unorthodox, unfaithful, and unfit to make adult decisions about what they need to hear and who they want to have say it?

The problem is that in the face of opposition they have also been unafraid.

What shall we think about that? Think David, maybe, who confronted the giant Goliath; think Moses, perhaps, who faced the Red Sea with an Egyptian army at his back; think Judith and her handmaiden, certainly, who routed Holofernes and saved the city; think Shifra and Puah, without doubt, who refused the order to murder Jewish newborns and so saved the nation. Think Mary of Nazareth and Mary of Magdala who stood as independent women alone and unblinking. Think moment of decision.

Then think of the foundresses of every religious order you have ever known who came to the United States without money, without professional resources, often without the language, and commonly without support — even from the church — to deal head on with the social justice questions of their time and so saved the church in the process.

"Women & Spirit," the traveling museum exhibit mounted by the Leadership Conference of Women Religious that reviews the story of women's religious communities in the United States, bears witness to the role of religious life in church and society. It is the visual history of women who made astounding choices at all the crossroads in national history and made them when women were allowed to make few, if any, choices at all.

It is a story too often forgotten and too easily domesticated. "That's just what sisters were supposed to be doing," people say. Oh, please.

These were women who opened schools for girls in a world that considered the education of women a useless and uppity waste.

These were women who nursed soldiers on both battlefields of the Civil War, North and South, in an age when sisters didn't work with men at all, let alone nurse them.

These were women who worked with what was left of a Native American society that had been stripped of its dignity, robbed of its lands and denied its civil rights in a culture that defined both the American Indian and the women who served them as less than fully human.

NCR: February 17-March 1, 2012

Subscribe to NCR to get all the news and special features that aren't always available online. In this issue:

- Conscience Roundup
Hear what theologians, commentators, and our editors have to say about the contraception mandate

- Special Section: Religious Life
Work of missioners, past and future; African meetings; and more

- Tribute to a Peacemaker
New York's Pax Christi fetes Daniel Berrigan

Subscribe now!

These were women who taught blacks for centuries and then walked with them in Selma, Ala., to claim their full humanity — attack dogs at their heels, fire hoses in front of them -- and met disdain everywhere from Christians who used religion to justify first slavery and, after it, segregation.

These were women who gave their lives to insert Catholic children into a Protestant society as equal participants in the democratic dream all the way to a Catholic presidency.

Indeed, for hundreds of years, over and over again, women religious have found themselves at the junction between past and future. For hundreds of years they have consistently, persistently, confidently and courageously chosen for a necessary future — whatever difficulties the doing of it meant for them in the present. Over and over again, they chose for tomorrow rather than settle for a more convenient past.

The entire history of religious life in this nation has been a history of crisis and response, of need and resistance, of response and reaction.

It was not an easy time.

At a time when the sick died uncared for, and the uneducated died illiterate and the poor or addicted died destitute and minorities died invisible to the rest of society, women religious chose to challenge any and every system for the sake of the coming of the reign of God.

And in the end, they succeeded. But don't be fooled: They did not succeed because their numbers were large or their influence was great or their social support was either broad-based or obvious. They succeeded because they refused to allow the ideas of the past to become the cement of the future. They succeeded because of the courage of women who went where they were told not to go.

Now we are at another crossroads moment in time. This is a time, too, of deep crisis and great needs, of the rejection of those who raise new questions and a reaction against those who raise new ideas in a system trying to preserve the old ones in order to preserve itself.

It is a time, as it has always been, for leadership.

But leadership and authority are not the same thing. It can take a long time to learn the difference between the two but there is nothing in life that demonstrates the difference between the two better than a crossroad.

At the crossroads in life, authority goes one direction: back. Authority goes in the direction that's already in the book; the path that has been clearly trod before now, the way that is safe and sure, clear and certain, obedient and approved, applauded and rewarded.

Leadership, on the other hand, rewrites the book. It takes the direction that leads only to the promise of a better tomorrow for everyone however difficult it may be to achieve it now. "The seed," the Zen master teaches, "never sees the flower."

The times are clear. The needs are now. The time for new decisions is upon us. Authority is not enough for times such as these. We need leaders now.

As women religious meet in Dallas these days as a "Leadership Conference" rather than as a conference of "Major Superiors," may God raise up women among them who will lead.

It is a new period of crisis. We must determine to meet this challenge to spiritual maturity, to human adulthood now as did our foremothers before us meet theirs. We, too, must move beyond fear to the real, real faith that can, we have seen, move mountains.

It is another period in which public and even ecclesiastical approval must be second again to the needs of those who look to us for both vision and voice.

It is a period in which we must not forego reaching for what is necessary because others tell us it is not acceptable.

For the sake of religious life, for the sake of women everywhere, and, in the end, for the sake of the very integrity of the church itself, we are looking to you now to be "Women of Spirit." May we be to our age what our ancestors were to theirs. Whatever the cost to ourselves.

For that, we are depending now on you.

[Benedictine Sr. Joan Chittister is a frequent NCR contributor.]

* * *

Coverage Note: NCR editor Tom Fox is in Dallas for the LCWR meeting. Read his dispatches from Dallas on the NCR Today blog and follow him on Twitter at twitter.com/ncrtomfox and twitter.com/NCRonline. If you are tweeting from the meeting include #LCWR in your tweets.

* * *

We can send you an e-mail alert every time Sr. Joan Chittister's column, "From Where I Stand," is posted to NCRonline.org. Go to this page and follow directions: E-mail alert sign-up. If you already receive e-mail alerts from us, click on the "update my profile" button to add "From Where I Stand" to your list.

Stories in this series of NCR's coverage of the national assembly of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious:

The report is misleading.

The report is misleading. Religious from the beginning of this nation arent under a cloud. Only those that have said its time we move beyong Christ.

You're wrong, of course.

You're wrong, of course. Know-Nothings investigated and burned convents in the 19th century. Cities passed laws to prohibit convents in neighborhoods. Etc. Get a clue.

Why do you dissidents

Why do you dissidents continue to call yourselves Catholic? By rejecting even just one Church teaching, you are by definition a heretic and outside the Ark of Salvation.

LOL

LOL

LOL is right! Jesus was a

LOL is right!
Jesus was a dissident of the Pharisees within his "system" also.
Boy, O boy... if Jesus isn't "saved," then we're all in trouble!

Wake up fool! Ignorant and

Wake up fool! Ignorant and innocent is not wisdom. Our Lord God, Savior and Spirit Guide Comforter calls us to stand up for our belies, not to cower down to the irreverent patriarchy!

In fact, disobedience to our

In fact, disobedience to our greatest Patriarch (GOD) is what has caused our fallen human nature. Did the disciples not exercise obedience to Christ? And if priests are "in persona Christi" shouldn't we listen to them, especially the Pope.

By your definition, 100% of

By your definition, 100% of priest I know are heretics, as are 100% of seminarians and 100% of every Bishop I have encountered.

Hello Tom, I don't mind

Hello Tom,
I don't mind calling myself a Catholic, for that is what I hope I am--someone who wants all men and women on the face of this planet to know they are loved by the Creator who made them and loved also by those who know themselves loved right now by that same Mind and Heart. I'm not concerned with being in an Arc of Salvation if others are left outside.

The work is urgent. The Good News is for the whole world. The present Roman set up is so focused on "tradition" that it seems incapable of using modern day insights re psychology and sociology and many other ologies to move to a point where sensitivity towards those hurt by the church ensures movements towards appropriate care. A measure of such sensitivity would be to recognise that children who have been abused by priests or religious are not likely to grow up seeking such people out to confide in. Indeed when they have been brave enough to do just that they have often been spurned, rejected as liars and payed off to remain silent. Evil heaped on evil does not speak of a loving relationship with God.
Developing alternative human resources would help reach out to more people--especially those with very real trust issues. Having women priests would go some way to Rome atlast recognising inclusiveness and therapeutic benefits. Jesus was a healer. We must develop these gifts too and not just mumbo-jumbo superstitions but empathetic reaching out. Men and women are called to be priests so each vocation should be welcomed once tested.

Much work is already being done within religious communities and parishes as well as beyond these organisations but gathering such resources together to learn from each other is an ongoing challenge. Sacramental life for those who seek it is very difficult to find as priest numbers dwindle in the West and as many people have walked away unable to respect those who deliver half hearted cold addresses which destroy faith and community.

You stay a member of a "Club" if you like Tom. I want life in all its abundance and to share it with everyone who will receive it.

Dear Tom A, Perhaps you too

Dear Tom A, Perhaps you too are perplexed about some of the writings on this board. Many calling themselves Catholic do not have the foggiest idea of what is taught by the Catholic Church. They question everything as though nothing is sacred. The Hierarchy is a big zero although the beginnings of the Catholic Church was established by Jesus Christ. I had always thought the immutable teachings by those in Authority through succession were believed by all as the Catholic Church is One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic. Today we read it is anything but. Jesus Christ did teach us that the Church would be under continuous attack but never did I believe that these attacks would come from Catholics. We have Christ's assurance that HIS Church would be under HIS care until the end of the world. Praise be to Jesus Christ now and forever. Amen!

What is moving beyond Chrisy?

What is moving beyond Chrisy? Is it a rich clergy with golden crosses and chalices, yards of red indicating kingship,is it being deferred to by others because you are male and certainly NO God, Father, Son, or Spirit would ever call women to serve in Priesthood?!!

You forgot to mention the

You forgot to mention the lace. Those boys LOVE to wear lace with their red dresses!

Yes, Fan of John XXIII, your

Yes, Fan of John XXIII, your namesake loved papal ceremony (with all the lace trimmings) more than any other 20th Century Pope.

Oh, my. This gave me a

Oh, my. This gave me a much-needed chuckle as I write a 15+ page catalogue of all the things that our priest bought for our new Church (including vestments). Holy shopping spree! The task, alone, is testing my willingness to stay the course.

"Beyong Christ"???????

"Beyong Christ"??????? Really?

Oh, Pleeze! That is not what

Oh, Pleeze! That is not what is being said!

You've got to be kidding!

You've got to be kidding! How many were kicked out their (later well received) congragations! Religious Founders almost always suffered under a black cloud for wanting a contextual theology...it's practically axiomatic that to really follow the gospel you will first be reviled by the church "authorities".

Your theology is a accurate

Your theology is a accurate as your spelling.

...and your grammar

...and your grammar

Right? However, small

Right? However, small mistakes (beyong Christ) often underline a more misleading problem!

Sr Joan, as always, has

Sr Joan, as always, has nailed the problem right on the head again.
What is the problem? Why what other than all of the old geezers at the Vatican of course. They have forgotten what real "faith" is - they still think it is religiosity! "Obey and Hide" is their "Creed"!

The stand out line in Sr Joan's article is - " they refused to allow the ideas of the past to become the cement of the future".

This should be required by

This should be required by every Bishop in every diocese to be read from the pulpit this Sunday-------while there still is a pulpit and still people in the pews to hear the reading! In a perfect Christian world, then the congregation would elect a sufficient number of women for that parish to be priests. Lacking that, I will find a legitimate Christian church where Jesus is honored. Amen! [65 yr. old male cradle Catholic]

OH Sr. Joan, you said it so

OH Sr. Joan, you said it so well to all of us who believe, to Catholic and non Catholic, to women and men, it is freedom, freedom to truly follow in the foosteps and make a choice for, not a choice in opposition. Bless you sister I too pray for leadership and not only in the church.

I was also an "old male

I was also an "old male cradle Catholic", and the Lord has led me to a wonderful legitimate Christian catholic Lutheran community led by wonderful female pastor.

Too bad all the hypocrites

Too bad all the hypocrites here wouldn't follow you, sir. May God bless you for your honesty. While I am saddened that you left the Holy Roman Catholic Church, at least you had the courage of your convictions and left, rather than staying on and pretending to be something you clearly are not.

Pax Christi

Amen! Beautifully worded -

Amen! Beautifully worded - thank you Sr. Joan!

Once again, Joan Chittister

Once again, Joan Chittister makes me want to stand up and cheer. She has issued a rallying call for the women attending the Leadership Conference and for all women in the church. As Chittister has indicated, nuns have demonstrated tremendous courage in the past without regard for their "carrers" or well being. Let us pray that those attending the Leadership Conference in Dallas demonstrate that same courage that has been the hallmark of nuns and the unselfish services they provide.

Chittister only demonstrated

Chittister only demonstrated nunly courage from before the end of the Second Vatican Council. Is Sr. Chittister a closet traditionalist? I wish nuns since the council were doing all the awesome things they were doing before.

Time does not stand still,

Time does not stand still, and the needs of today are met in different ways than they were yesterday. It's the crossroad Sr Chittister speaks of. The nuns I know are still doing awesome things and still deserve our gratitude.

Peace and blessings

Jamie, As I read the article,

Jamie, As I read the article, I think what Sr. Chittister is saying is that, like the old days, the nuns of today are finding that they are isolated and with little support. Yet, like the pioneering sisters of before, they are relying on their faith to carry them thru these difficult, and often, lonely times. I also think that she is saying that the challenges of today are different then the ones of yesterday, but the same commitment to following the guidance of the Holy Spirit, is what has not changed.

Peace and God's blessing to you, Jamie

But she only gave examples

But she only gave examples from the old days. In the old days, sisters built schools and hospitals as their way of following the Holy Spirit. Now they write NCR columns about how they used to run schools and hospitals. Did Sr. Chittister give any examples of what sisters are doing now?

Jamie, I think that is a good

Jamie, I think that is a good point and thank you for bring it up. As much as I think my reading of the article is a good reading of it, I agree, there should have been examples of the work that the sisters of today are doing. And how that work shows that the spirit of old is still a spirit alive in the sisters of today. It just would have been a more complete piece.

Jamie R on Aug. 11, 2010.

Jamie R on Aug. 11, 2010.

You stated:

"Chittister only demonstrated nunly courage from before the end of the Second Vatican Council. Is Sr. Chittister a closet traditionalist? I wish nuns since the council were doing all the awesome things they were doing before."
------------------------------------
Oh really! Prove what you stated about Sr. Joan with examples.

Sisters are doing all the awesome things now that they were doing before.
1) I personally know of a Sister who has worked for 25 years (she's an American) in a remote Indian village in British Columbia. There is no parish priest there---she runs the parish, began the town's only infirmary---a little hospital, prepares people for all the sacraments, the parish's social life. A priest comes through every 2-3 months by plane---if he can get in.

2) I know of Sisters working in the back-waters of South Carolina---tutoring Africian American children in their school work every day. They work with high school youngsters who want to go to college---but wouldn't be prepared otherwise. They gather clothing for the really poor for the chilly winter months. They personally stood off angry neighbors (at each other) who wanted to burn houses down over a disagreement. The Sisters saved more lives that day than one could imagine. Their example and life-style (and they don't wear veils) has led the people to state that the Catholic Church really 'shows the face of Jesus.' Hows that coming from Baptists?

3) I know of an American Sister who placed herself in danger this summer in going over to the Ukraine (political climate is changing) to tutor college students in English at a Byzantine Catholic College. The government wants to close that College.

The Sisters are STILL modeling the Christ-way of living lives----they just don't make the newspaper headlines in acting this way.

What I stated is that Sr.

What I stated is that Sr. Chittister only gave pre-Conciliar examples. I'm not saying sisters aren't presently doing good things, such as the examples you gave; I'm saying that when asked what the LCWR is doing, they give examples of how, in the past, they built schools and hospitals, and, in the present, they speak at conferences and write for NCR about women's ordination, etc.

What is the LCWR doing, by and large? That a few sisters doing important work doesn't mean that, on the whole, the LCWR is still doing important work. In fact, Chittister's argument seems to be specifically that sisters need to stop doing the work that they were doing. She lists all these good things American sisters did, then says that we need leaders who rewrite the book, who go different places where they're told not to go. The sisters who are teaching Black children in the South, serving the Indian community, or teaching at a Catholic college are doing what sisters have been doing for a long time. Chittister is calling for sisters to be leaders who follow the Spirit only to do new things, to develop a new sort of religious life, etc.

jamie r on Aug. 12, 2010.

jamie r on Aug. 12, 2010.

You stated:

"What I stated is that Sr. Chittister only gave pre-Conciliar examples. I'm not saying sisters aren't presently doing good things, such as the examples you gave; I'm saying that when asked what the LCWR is doing, they give examples of how, in the past, they built schools and hospitals, and, in the present, they speak at conferences and write for NCR about women's ordination, etc.

What is the LCWR doing, by and large? That a few sisters doing important work doesn't mean that, on the whole, the LCWR is still doing important work. In fact, Chittister's argument seems to be specifically that sisters need to stop doing the work that they were doing. She lists all these good things American sisters did, then says that we need leaders who rewrite the book, who go different places where they're told not to go. The sisters who are teaching Black children in the South, serving the Indian community, or teaching at a Catholic college are doing what sisters have been doing for a long time. Chittister is calling for sisters to be leaders who follow the Spirit only to do new things, to develop a new sort of religious life, etc."
-------------------------------------------------
The LCWR is the LEADERSHIP representatives of all of these orders. Well who do you think AUTHORIZES all of these ministries that the American Sisters are in? Who sees to it that the Sisters have what they need to carry out these ministries?

And all of the Sisters that I mentioned are past 55 years of age. Years ago, there would have been Sisters in their 20's and 30's doing these ministries. The LCWR faces a question of trying to do as much or more with fewer members, and older members. It also requires teaching the laity who are Associates Members what the spirit and thrust of the ministry (specific ministries). It means working with new (civil) laws and specific diocesan regulations in dealing with sociological ministries. You spoke about a 'few' sisters----there are several Sisters involved. There wasn't the space to list everything every Sister does in every community/congregation. Perhaps you need to do more investigation to find out how much and how many Sisters are involved. And even when the Sisters get too old to minister to the public, they form the support team behind those that do. A Sister's ministry (even if she is bed-ridden) isn't over until she dies. Spiritual ministry is VITALLY important. And the elderly Sisters are a powerhouse of prayer.

Back in the olden days, the Mother Provincial would get on a buckboard or train to visit these ministries where her Sisters worked. Now, the Leaders hop on planes to see what and how the Sisters are doing around the world.

The Sisters formed the LCWR because there are so many similar needs and problems that they face across congregational lines, that being together and discussing things together is a great support. Each member of the leadership sits on executive boards dealing with hospitals, universities, nursing care homes, hospices, prisons, shealters for the homeless, homes for exceptional children/youth----they deal with planning committees for soup kitchens, homes for abused women and children---and this is just with what their own community is involved. They are a vital part of their own communities continued ministries as well as dealing with broader issues that the American Sisters face today.

Instead of criticizing what the LCWR does, Jamie, you should contact one of them---and ask her what all she does. I don't care which one you contact---you would be surprised (and probably exhaused just hearing their schedule) what all they do.

I'm not criticizing the LCWR

I'm not criticizing the LCWR directly. I'm criticizing Sr. Chittister's column. That you have 3 anecdotes of sisters doing important work doesn't change my criticism of Chittister's rhetoric. She gave examples of sisters doing great things previously, and then said that the sisters need leaders to take them on a new path. If what sisters were doing is so great, why do they need to rewrite the book? And why are all the sisters in your anecdotes over 55?

I'm not criticizing what the LCWR does. I'm asking what they do by and large. As a regular reader of this website, I have the impression that in the past they built schools and hospitals, etc., and today they go around speaking prophetically. Unless NCR distorts its reporting to make the sisters look frivolous, it appears that LCWR is much more concerned with being prophetic/following the 'Spirit', etc., than they are with actually doing anything concretely. Likewise, Sr. Chittister's column seems to be entirely about women religious doing something new, something different from what they used to do. If what they used to do was run schools and hospitals, then whatever new thing they do when they rewrite the book will be something other than running schools and hospitals.

I'm not saying that there are no sisters doing good things. I'm not saying that there are no sisters in LCWR-congregations who are doing good things. I'm saying that if you ask Sr. Chittister or NCR what sisters do, you're going to get some vague crap about rewriting the book and speaking prophetically, and no emphasis on things like actual ministries or recruiting sisters to make sure those actual ministries continue to be done.

For instance, from the

For instance, from the outgoing LCWR president's speech:

"We also found ourselves quavering with the continued ecclesial inquiries and canonical assessments, shocked by the planetary quakes in Haiti and Chile, Turkey and Mexico, the Gulf oil spill, mudslides in China, and disturbed by emerging news about sex abuse scandals around the world -- not to mention the quakes that health care reform generated within our church and country."

What's wrong with this? Anyone can be shocked by earthquakes. There's no leadership in being shocked at an earthquake, or at sex abuse (there's even less leadership in LCWR's reaction to SNAP). I mean, if LCWR sisters are doing great things, why are they talking about being shocked by earthquakes, and not about helping victims? If the LCWR is still doing the great works of previous sisters, then why would the outgoing president say that they had gone through a deconstruction, and were now "in the time of the Resurrection Waltz of re-integration," whatever that means? The picture that NCR and Chittiser present of LCWR is that it's an assembly of elderly, wannabe Prophets riding on the coattails of sisters who cared more about doing than about 'Leading.'

Jamie since you are such an

Jamie since you are such an ageist re women why are you not an ageist re Dope Benedict and all his MOST REVEREND OVER THE HILS?
You are a sexist all-male exclusivista that's why. You can hardly wait to try and put women down. That's their place right? Makes people like you comfortable.
Your blather is truely worthless.

I'm not an ageist. I have

I'm not an ageist. I have nothing against old people (I am ageist against children, however. One day you'll be an adult and realize that calling the Pope 'Dope Benedict' and the Bishops 'MOST REVEREND OVER THE HILLS' is childish and not at all clever). Religious congregations should have many old people. They certainly shouldn't kick out the old. Having old people isn't a problem. Not having young people is. Old people die. That's what they do. They've been doing it forever, and there's no reason to believe they'll stop. If the only people doing the important work of the sisters are over 55, then the sisters have failed and are failing. What sisters do is important. It would be unfortunate if there were no more sisters to do what it is sisters do.

How can I be an all-male exclusivista? I believe you mean excluvisto, or possibly excluvistus.

How am I putting women down? Many women do many wonderful, important things. On the other hand, the LCWR, as reported by the NCR, talks about being prophetic and rewriting the book on all the great things they used to do. I'm not trying to put down women. I'm putting down talking about being prophetic, rewriting the book, and being shocked by planetary quakes without talking about concretely doing anything to help anybody.

NCR devotes a considerable amount of space to supporting the LCWR against the visitation. NCR devotes either no or very little space to reporting on what LCWR does. Whereas the sisters of old did many things, contemporary sisters say many things. Again, the sisters don't seem to need leadership now so much as they need to do things.

There are many nuns

There are many nuns PreVatican II and Post Vatican II that are still doing the awesome things each and every single day.

They are! Get a clue! They

They are! Get a clue! They are doing more than before "the council".Open your eyes!!!!

Look around you and open your

Look around you and open your eyes to reality. Congregations infested by the likes of Joan Chittister are growing old and in their barrenness borne of rebellion and disobedience, are quickly fading away. After you come to terms with this reality, look beyond these "career" feminuns and note the congregations of orthodox, obedient, loyal to the Holy See, nuns, which are springing up all over the country and thriving with so many vocations that they have not the space to contain them! Thank God and His Divine Justice that the Joansies of the world are croaking away with no one to replace them! Soon they will be but a whisper of a dark and troubled brief period of time in the history of the Church. Would that her kind would repent and return to the nun of their vows before it be too late and they die in the midst of their pride.

What country are you living

What country are you living in? How can you be so completely out of touch with the reality of the true dismal state of affairs in the Church today? Congregations of nuns "springing up all over the country?" - what country???

This country. As the old die

This country. As the old die off, the young are joining vibrant communities who still do the works of charity that the old nuns used to do. My sister-in-law's order has started about 10 new missions in the last 5 years. Our old babysitter's order had about 20 young women join each year, and the word gets out about them almost through word of mouth. They certainly don't have the publicity or NCR bully pulpit that sister joan has, yet their lives are so much more attractive to the young that they have a tough time keeping up with the new applicants. http://nashvilledominican.org/Home

Thus it has always been for religions. Read the sociologist Rodney Stark's book The Rise of Christianity, if you want a secular perspective on the dying off and rise of various U.S. denominations. It isn't too much of a stretch to apply the same principals to religious orders.

Indeed the traditional orders

Indeed the traditional orders are innundated with vocations. Loyalty to Christ and his Church bears fruit. Self-service does not.
As we sadly watch the types of orders that Sr Joan espouses die. They have lost their way, its all about them, very sad. Once great, now a remnant trying to re-write the Gospels and Church history. Perhaps a faith community of another sort would be more suitable to their needs. False though they are.

well said. thank you. the

well said. thank you. the army of laity that sr. joan and her ilk think is with them is not there. we people in the pews do not want what sr. joan thinks we should have - as another person said - she needs to quit trying to save us, just join us in being faithful to the Pope and the bishops.

abby schult says "she needs

abby schult says "she needs to quit trying to save us, just join us in being faithful to the Pope and the bishops."

Sister Joan should just be an air head like you and join "us", meaning you & your blind ilk, and let the Pope and the Bishops abuse women forever?

Aren't Church "leaders" supposed to teach the Gospels, set an example of Christ? Tell us, how is the Pope and the Bishops in the US being faithful to the Gospels when for hundreds of years they abused children and built palaces for themselves to live in while the poor went hungry?

Get serious!

Amen, when I think of Joan

Amen, when I think of Joan Chittister, I think of aging orders whose average age is climbing into the 60's, who are stepping out of parish life and into retirement to live comfortable lives off of their endowments, whose relevance to parish and diocesan life is fading into oblivion, and who blame everyone but themselves for their failure to attract the young with the bright light of Christ. A life dedicated to whining isn't going to attract young women. The several young women I know who have joined convents in the last several years (including one in the last week) avoid the Sr. Joans of the world like the plague. Their language is that of bitterness and cynicism. Their attitudes are sour and the attractiveness of their lives to the young is zilch.

Douglas, You seem to want to

Douglas, You seem to want to blame the women religious for the men's lack of leadership in the Church for the past forty years. The Titanic Roman Catholic Church has hit an iceberg and now it blames the women that it is sinking!! Now the men in the hierarchy want all the life boats for themselves. Such humility! What chivalry from these men in our own Church towards the women in our own Church - and you seem to think taking the side of these men is the right thing to do, because they said so and they told you at EWTN!

The women religious have been doing their part, rolling up their sleeves and doing the hard work, living simply, serving God and serving the poor, while your overstuffed and puffed up bloated big fat-cat male women-haters in the Vatican do NOTHING now but whine, feel sorry for themselves and parade around pompously and full of pride in themselves in red silk and their brocade gold embroidered dresses and lace, pointy stupid ass hats, red shoes and destroy all semblance of the teachings of the Gospels and Jesus Christ, ignoring the poor and making themselves rich!!

Women are sick and tired of the typical male empty tin can chatter from these hypocrites and their equally ignorant hand picked male women-haters from Opus Dei at EWTN! Women are sick of the attitudes of these men toward women and their ignorance of God and sick of their denial of the Holy Spirit at work in women!

You want to call that "whining" - go right ahead! You'll be hearing a lot more of it!! Because women have been and are going to do a lot more than the stupid idiot males in the Vatican who are ruining the Church into the dust of unconsciousness! The men have done a great job at ruining Faith itself! Open your eyes! Are you happy about that? Are you happy about seeing the Church fail and fall apart into insignificance over the fact that the men have decided to take Jesus and the Holy Spirit right out of the Church?

The attitudes of the women religious are far sweeter and more Christ-like than the poisonous snakes in the Vatican with their lust for inquisition against women religious, their lust for power and glory and riches for themselves and their own selfish immature agenda. These same men could not clean up their own filthy ACTS against children who were being raped and molested by their fellow priest friends. They love perverts and child molesters more than they do women and this is why you will be hearing from women in the Church who are disgusted with their style of leadership that says we cannot even question their behavior and their ACTS of betrayal against humanity in general!

For your information, if the men in the hierarchy were really spiritually mature and connected to Jesus, we would not be having this discussion. We are having this discussion due to the failures of the men in the hierarchy who refuse to be spiritual and refuse to be honest with themselves and everyone and refuse to mature, refuse to hear the women religious out. The men in the hierarchy are just a little too willing to get their pitchforks out against women! Furthermore, they are rearing a male laity, such as yourself, of empty tin cans that love to whine and be waited on hand and foot by women and are against women any chance they can possibly get. That's the truth whether you agree with it or not. It is the sick truth about the all male hierarchy that is too puffed up and stiff necked to even bother themselves to be equal partners with women in our love for God and in serving God's purposes!

And another thing - try to put yourself in a woman's shoes for a bit and get a clue as to the source of bitterness and cynicism of having to witness men who really think they are better and superior than women, who think they are more superior than God! The women are frankly sick of witnessing your mean spirited and backward ugly faces of hypocrisy and lies!

Dream on all you want that you believe older really religious women are retiring "to live comfortable lives off their endowments." Wishful thinking! You wish that we would!!! The entire reason for the inquisition of women religious is for the old men's club in the hierarchy to get a hold of any "endowment" away from these women religious. Wake up! You have no idea what you are talking about! All the men in the hierarchy want is an excuse, any excuse to get their MONEY or any assets from property they can get their grubby filthy malicious hands on! You need to wake up into the light of Christ!

Hooray for you anonymous

Hooray for you anonymous catholic! That's the Holy Spirit! You tell the Truth in no uncertain terms. Good for you. God be with you and let your Truth be heard around the world. Let other voices rise up. Rise up and be heard.

This elevator does ot go to

This elevator does ot go to the top floor! LOL

GabrielEspi on Aug. 12, 2010.

GabrielEspi on Aug. 12, 2010.

You stated:

"Look around you and open your eyes to reality. Congregations infested by the likes of Joan Chittister are growing old and in their barrenness borne of rebellion and disobedience, are quickly fading away. After you come to terms with this reality, look beyond these "career" feminuns and note the congregations of orthodox, obedient, loyal to the Holy See, nuns, which are springing up all over the country and thriving with so many vocations that they have not the space to contain them! Thank God and His Divine Justice that the Joansies of the world are croaking away with no one to replace them! Soon they will be but a whisper of a dark and troubled brief period of time in the history of the Church. Would that her kind would repent and return to the nun of their vows before it be too late and they die in the midst of their pride."
------------------------------------------------------

You should open your eyes and heart to what you are stating. You don't know a thing---except what someone has told you on TV (EWTN). The so-called "orthodox, obedient, loyal to the Holy See" that you are referring to are also very PROUD---and think that they and only THEY---can teach or nurse the laity. "The laity are" (and I am quoting one that I spoke with this summer stated) "only empty tin cans that need to be filled. They know nothing of God. We, wearing our habits---startle and surprise them, and give them what they would not have otherwise."

And GabrielEspi---they are calling you an 'empty tin can.' Why---because empty tin cans only make a lot of noise---because nothing is in them.

And these communities are not springing up all over the country---just a few places here and there. They are very limited in what they can do or will offer to do.

I can only add my support and

I can only add my support and prayer for Sr. Joan and for all women religious. Her words of wisdom and action speak volumes for the courage these women show in the face of great personal risk and with out there tireless efforts, Jesus Church would not have been able to carry out it's mission. All of you supporters of the more traditional pre-vatican ways have only to look at EWTN and how it was founded to know that all nuns, more traditional or progressive have created the backbone of Catholic education. How many of the male conservatives who support blindly the Bishops and Pope have nuns from these same orders to thank for there faith. If they are so bad, who do you have to thank for your relationship with God. In my case, it was good nuns and faithful priest who worked tirelessly side by side and with respect for each other. We must all be willing to work for the Kingdom together and if we are divided how can we expect to carry out our Mission for Jesus and his church.

- And leave no-one behind. -

- And leave no-one behind.
- Carry the 'traditional' religious for their awakening will come when their 'young' sisters leave their adolescence.
- Carry those 'traditional' religious who gave men like Rode the warped idea that 'non-traditional' women religious were failing the church. They soon will realize that the quality of their 'traditional' life can never be measured against the lives of others who live in obedience to their constitutions and charisms, and the Gospel.
- Carry the hierarchy. For those men in the Curia and in the episcopacy of the United States will have sacrificed the Church in the USA for the sake of a vision that is not Christian.

Leave the doors open, the windows unlatched, the welcome mat on the porch so that those who scorn you now will find a way to you.

Remember that you are women, not hierarchs. Act always as the People of God for your place is in that flat plain where all are equal before God. With the Church call the hierarchy to task for the scandal that they have poured upon our heads.

This lady is an open heretic,

This lady is an open heretic, and a barbarian. She has writen about making abortions unnecessary. The deliberate taking of an innocent human life is never justified, never mind necessary. Such an act denies the absolute equality of all humans.

Spoken like a true EWTN

Spoken like a true EWTN fan(atic). Did you ever stop to think that this viewpoint is what is causing the empty pews? It is definitely not that of the Jesus I encounter in the Scriptures.

Long live Joan and her courageous Sisters!

Would you please learn to

Would you please learn to read! Sr. Joan said no such thing in this article. What do you want, to make abortions necessary?

I believe Anon was referring

I believe Anon was referring to a an interview she game, you can read it here.

http://familylifenz.wordpress.com/2010/02/19/lifesitenews-interview-sist...

Barbarian? Do you want to

Barbarian? Do you want to start counting the heads that rolled or the innocent bodies burned over the centuries due to the barbarianism of unbridled patriarchal church history that made the church so great and bloated. Start counting! Perhaps some scholars could let us know.
Now there is an abomination waiting to be blasted all over the place and it's not anti-catholic! It's anti the "Deepening Darkness"(read the book) of unbridled patriarchy.
Make no mistake. Tho it is a boy's club there are patriarchal women by the score. They simply agree with their own inferiority as long as they are comfortable and some quite successful.
Unbridled patriarchy, secular and religious, can be a threat to all men and women to the degree it is unbridled. The hall marks of the banking crisis that went global: Wall Street secrecy,exploitation of those kept in the dark and out of the loop of elite men in power bailed out by main street. Main Street is the 21st century muleteam (the new woman) for the Patriachal crowd on Wallstreet who are just as bloated as the Cappa Magna. They want their subjects to scrimp and toil to keep them in riches for the good of the country ... for the good of the church!
If you want real barbarianism how about studying the Inquisition, or the Crusades? How about the Children's Crusades? Now there's a window on the soul of how much the church cares about children. Ever read about the Albigensians or the French Huguenots or the Inquisition on the shores of America. It is wretched! When we say trust in God or Jesus is our alegiance simply to Patriarchy?
What about the brotherhood of "Warrior, Priests, and Weilders of power" that came to the New World and helped decimate native americans. Now those, and not native americans, are real barbatians and you can track their un broken lineage strait back to Rome.
The threatening post-modern barbarianism that exists today is Patriarchy unchecked and unbridled. It needs balance to be effective and functional. Without strong modifying opponents it can become profoundly dysfunctional for everyone.
The socioeconomic religious history of the RCC in this country exemplifies what barbarians in power can do. Rules and regulations govering property ownership in the Southwest where the Patriarchal church had its grip, even men had to become Catholic and swear allegiance to it in order to own property. How barbarian!!! Hey but it made a lot of great men go to church. Surely the men in power were convinced God was on their side. They had the might to make people say it was right.
You want to know what made the church better and way less barbaric? Women-religious. Active women-religious. It is that group of women who still carry the charism of their foundresses that unbridled patriarchy oppresses today. Too too too bad some people refuse to see.

Wow, Anonymous! Are you a

Wow, Anonymous! Are you a bishop?

If Sister Joan is an "open

If Sister Joan is an "open heretic & a barbarian", then so I am I !
If only we had WOMEN like her in ALL Church ministries, including the priesthood & episcopate,
we'd not be in the midst of the lingering, global, MALE clergy sex-abuse scandal.
+Saints Scholastica & Benedict, pray for us, & may our Lord richly bless Sr Joan & her vocation!

Anonymous on Aug. 11,

Anonymous on Aug. 11, 2010.

You stated:

"This lady is an open heretic, and a barbarian. She has writen about making abortions unnecessary. The deliberate taking of an innocent human life is never justified, never mind necessary. Such an act denies the absolute equality of all humans."
---------------------------------------------
A heresy is a statement made before the Church is willing to consider the facts of the statement.

I suppose in your mind, that women whose pregnancies put their lives in danger are barbarians when they are trying to save their own lives in order to care for other children or family members. Your form of Christianity is a "one-size fits all" brand. That is NOT how Jesus deals with us.

Joan--thank you for reminding

Joan--thank you for reminding all of us that we stand strong against injustice not because we are stubborn, but because it is right to do so. Stay strong women religious--a grateful Catholic community stands with you!

Thank you, Joan. You continue

Thank you, Joan. You continue to speak our truth in an open, honest manner.

Hurrah for Sr. Joan our

Hurrah for Sr. Joan our modern day prophet. On this feast of St. Clare, I pray that like her who did not back down when the male branch wanted her to change her rule,todays' women will have the Holy Spirit with them giving them strength to hold on to gospel living in spite of domination by the male heirarchy.

I hope "WANTED: women of

I hope "WANTED: women of spirit in our time" is read by everyone at the Leadership Conference.

Three cheers for this

Three cheers for this wonderfully written, well thought out, true and brave article. Well done.

At the crossroads in life, authority goes one direction: back. Authority goes in the direction that's already in the book; the path that has been clearly trod before now, the way that is safe and sure, clear and certain, obedient and approved, applauded and rewarded.

Leadership, on the other hand, rewrites the book. It takes the direction that leads only to the promise of a better tomorrow for everyone however difficult it may be to achieve it now. "The seed," the Zen master teaches, "never sees the flower."

AMEN

Who have done more for the

Who have done more for the people of God? God bless the sisters.

"Women of vision, with a

"Women of vision, with a prophetic voice in a time when that voice is desperately needed in our church and society," is how I think of women religious. The cost may ultimately be great, but for such a time as this, the cost is even greater if we allow fear to silence the voice!

Joan, thank you for you

Joan, thank you for you leadership and inspiration. I pray all women of faith will respond with the courage it requires to move our church and world forward.

Post new comment

NCR Comment code:

  1. Be respectful. Do not attack the writer. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  2. Use appropriate language. Avoid vulgarities and slurs.
  3. Keep to the point. Deliberate digressions don't aid the discussion.

For more detailed guidelines, visit our User Guidelines page.

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
(if you have one; if not, leave this blank)
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <font> <swf> <swf list>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may use <swf file="song.mp3"> to display Flash files inline

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This is to prove you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.