NCR on Kindle - NCR classifieds - YouTube - Twitter - Facebook - Email Alerts - RSS
Lessons learned in Haiti: From the mouths of babes
Commentary
I was fortunate enough to be in Haiti twice, once just three days after the earthquake and a second time during the third week post earthquake. My mind is filled with unforgettable experiences, but I want the children of Haiti to speak for themselves, so I will tell you their stories. Each one holds an important lesson for me and, quite possibly, for you, as well. Each child has a unique perception ... about life ... about Haiti’s political reality ... about faith ... about family ... about acceptance and most of all, about hope.
Pushon, 12-years-old, was one of the first children I met when I arrived on January 15th; three days after the earthquake had devastated Haiti. I was in Port-au-Prince, starting work in a makeshift hospital, set up in huge tents on the airport field. Pushon’s left leg was horribly crushed and held the odor of rotting flesh. Flies were gathering around the open wounds, bones were sticking out everywhere and the flesh was completely gone from the medial aspect of his lower leg. That leg looked like a picture from one of those anatomy books which shows muscles and vessels and bones, but it just wasn’t as neat as a picture. It was obvious we would have to amputate or he would die.
Pushon panicked when we told him. “No, no, no,” he begged, “I can wiggle my toes. See”, as he pointed to his toes. “You have a bad infection,” we explained, “You’re getting a fever. You will die soon if we do not cut off your leg.” He thought a full minute; a minute is a long time to wait for a 12 yr old to answer. He wet his lips before he spoke his mind. “My father needs me”, he said. “My mother is dead. My sisters are dead. My father needs me.”
Pushon knew what it meant to be an amputee in Haiti: unable to ride his bike, he would no longer be able to go to school or church. Children with deformities, moreover, were often shunned in school. Whether he did or didn’t go to school he would most likely never be able to get a job. In a country where that has an 80% unemployment rate, why would anyone hire a one-legged man when there were so many men with both legs?
At age 12 Pushon completely understood the social issues of his country.
He envisioned a future spent on the street begging, homeless, hungry, and dirty. There would be no Special Olympics for him, no school with handicapped access, no Rights of Disability Act passed by his Congress. He would need crutches for the rest of his life. He had never seen an artificial leg; he would never ride his bike again. Gone were his dreams of becoming a doctor.
Preview NCR's Family Life Issue
Watch this video from NCR Editor Dennis Coday for highlights from our annual Family Life special section.

You won't find these articles on our website. Subscribe now to receive all the content from each biweekly issue.
And yet he chose to live, not for himself, but because his father needed him. Abandoning his personal aspirations, the boy had asked himself, “What will my father do if I die?” He had seen the pain in his father’s face after losing the rest of his family to the earthquake. Pushon chose to have the surgery, thereby giving the most that he could give --his leg-- so that his father could have hope! Pushon taught me a lesson of love.
On Jan. 17, five days after the earthquake struck, thirteen-year-old Barbara arrived with a dirty rag covering her face, revealing only her left eye, which had severe swelling and deformity. Most physicians and nurses have one thing that gets to them. For me it’s facial deformities. I simply hate them. I steeled myself as I removed the rag. Barbara’s good eye was looking right at me and I didn’t want her to see me cringe. Inside a voice was screaming, “Look at this deformity!” I could see flesh hanging and some bone showing. Half her nose was missing and deep beyond the bone there were visible signs of the inner workings of the sinuses. I heard air rush in and out, and there was a lot of pus and a horrible smell.
I remember she is thirteen, and the whole time she is talking and talking, once in a while taking a deep breath when something I did hurt her as I attempted to clear away the pus to get a better look. I can understand a little Creole and she is talking about how her faith in God has helped her. “I knew God would never abandon me, “she says. “When I saw my mother and grandmother dead I knew God would take care of me. I had been wandering the streets for days and then God helped me find you. From the moment the earth started shaking, I felt God inside of me. I knew God would take care of me. When I saw my mother dead I knew that I had to rely on God more.”
Barbara would need major reconstructive and plastic surgery. When I explained that we would need to get her to the USA, she cried with joy in English, “Oh thanks you Jesu ... I knew you helps me!”
This is a thirteen-year-old whose mother was dead; whose grandmother was dead, who had no house, no food and no face, and all she could do was thank Jesus! Barbara taught me to have the faith of a child in all situations.
By Jan. 18, six days post earthquake, the food we had been promised had not yet arrived and hunger was spreading. As a medical team we’d been advised to bring enough food and water for three days, but by this time I had exhausted the peanut butter and granola bars I had brought.
I was attending to James, 17, who had a concrete wall fall on him. It crushed his pelvis, sending a metal bar through his upper leg, through his privates, and into the other leg. Bedridden, James wasn’t going anywhere, so I asked him to guard my duffle bag that held all my expensive “doctor instruments,” worth thousands of dollars. He took the job very seriously and when he was sleeping, he would put his arm through the straps.
I had almost forgotten that I had a ziplock bag of nuts, raisins, and chocolate chips in the duffle bag. When I remembered and retrieved the food, James was starring right at me. I hadn’t eaten anything in 12 hours and I was hungry. This boy hadn’t eaten anything in days. Still, this was the only food I had left and I had to keep working 20-22 hours a day. No one knew when the promised food would arrive. James was watching me. I took out a handful of nuts and handed them to him. He immediately turned to the person in the next cot and gave half his nuts away; that child turned to the person next to her and gave half her nuts away, and so this went on, down about 6 cots, until the last person got just a few nuts.
Haiti is a country that knows hunger. In fact, it is one of the hungriest countries on earth. James taught me how to share.
On Jan. 20, eight days post earthquake, I treated four-year-old Sande, one of the lucky ones. Her mother was alive and Sande only had a fractured leg. Once the fracture was reduced and put into a cast she had tons of energy. When the shipments of crutches and walkers began to arrive, we found a small walker for her. There was lots of foot traffic and noise in the tents and Sande being only 4 years old was tiny, and adorable with her tiny walker and pink cast, We taught her how to say, “Hey you!” and as she walked around she would yell, “Hey you!” which translated into “I am coming through…get out of my way”. As the days went on, the tents became more crowded and noisier and no one could hear Sande’s “Hey you," so she would get the attention of those in her way by giving the road blocker a gentle punch in the back of the leg!
Sande taught me that when you are little you sometimes need to give a gentle punch to get what you need.
On Feb. 8, 22 days after the earthquake, Nahomie arrived. The 12-year-old had a crushed leg. She was evacuated to the northern region of Haiti where some of us were now tending the wounded. Her leg was amputated. The child was missing her mother who was miles away in Port au Prince
Nahomie was the patient who would hold the stump of her leg and cry the most. Every time she cried, I would give her a dose of morphine to settle her down and allow her to sleep. The passage of time didn’t slow her crying. I thought, It’s two weeks past surgery. She must be dealing with phantom pain.” Then one day as she was crying I put my hands around her face and she reached for me. I sat on her cot and she put her head on my lap, wrapped her arms around me, held me tight, the crying stopped, I held her and she went to sleep. It was then that I got it ... she needed human touch. Her mother was far away and her leg had been cut off. She didn’t need morphine; she needed someone to sit with her and hold her. From then on, I did a lot of holding.
Nahomie taught me to forget the drugs ... and remember the person!!
On Feb. 17, 36 days post earthquake, a U.S. military helicopter brought 11-year-old Peterson to our hospital in the north of Haiti. He had a fractured femur with an external fixation, metal rods sticking out of his leg. Peterson was one of our orphans. He didn’t know if any family member had survived. Every day he would ask for a phone and call his mother. No answer. Still, he kept trying several times a day. Then one day he called his mother again and -- she answered! The boy shouted, “Ma Ma” and cried with joy. We cried and cheered!! She was injured but alive. The house they had lived in had collapsed and she was rescued and taken for medical care. She asked a relative to search for her cell phone in the rubble of what had been their home. She knew it was the only way she could find her four children -- all of whom were on their way home from school when the earthquake struck. Her children all knew her cell phone number.
Peterson taught me: Don’t give up too soon.
These are the stories of just six whose lives were changed by the earthquake. Each, in turn, has changed my life. I am a different person because I met them.
[This is a keynote address by Mercy Sr. Karen Schneider, a pediatrician and instructor at Johns Hopkins, delivered Feb. 24 at Loyola University Maryland, in Baltimore for a Haiti benefit/fund raising event.]





I have so much...and complain
I have so much...and complain over nothing.
Thank you for these stories.
Thank you for these stories. I am given the gift of hope through these little children that know their God, are filled with compassion and joy and never give up even in these worst of circumstances. For them and for all Haitians I pray that as time passes we do not forget what they have and are suffering. It is so easy to get on with our lives even while they can't. We need to continue helping.
I hope I am a different
I hope I am a different person because I read her stories...
Lessons to be learned a)
Lessons to be learned
a) about haiti
b) the NCR : fiond it impossible to send you emails that do not come back
Haiti Chile
The Globe editorial "Chile Holds up, Haiti falls down" (Thursday
March 4) got to the point: Societies developed in areas, “frequently “struck by Earthquakes, should build in the perspective of Earth Quakes. This is he difference between Haiti and Chile correctly emphasized by the Globe: the Chileans built houses and cities in the perspective of Earth quakes; the Haitian did not as they were "truly underdeveloped".
But here the Historic foundations of Cultural Political differences come into play:
The Chilean Society was developed by Christian Spain, which slaves treated as
humans and who respected Slave families. Actually all slaves in Latin America were treated in this Humane way, in keeping with the early Medieval Christian Laws. Especially in Brazil where Africans could mix Voodoo and Christian liturgies.
In contrast with Latin America, the Haitian Society was based on French "Enlightenment-modern market law": slaves were objects; instruments of production to be traded. Marriage was prohibited, male slaves having to run around for sex on Sundays. These inhumane laws were the foundations of the Haitian Social and Political consciousness, after the Slaves expelled their masters at the Napoleonic end of the French Revolution. Where were the human models the slaves could find in their Childhood and develop in adults’ life”? Even worse, these utterly deprived “Slaves”,, now “independent” but left alone in their Human Misery, were compelled in the 1820s to pay France, a
fantastic sum as indemnity for taking "assets" away from France. This sum, of course, only extorted from the still essentially slaves by their “Mulatto” (?) short term masters until the next pseudo-government breakdown.
Compare now how the cultural foundations of Chile and New England helped these populations to develop well working Modern Societies and to think ahead on the Future, in the case of Chile to possible Earth Quakes. And How utterly difficult the emergence from slavery, poor
sex and racial inequalities (Mulattoes vs. Blacks) ) prevented the latter Haiti to conceive and achieve tasks, which seem natural to us descendants of Scots, English, Spaniards and Respected Indians in Chile.
Cultural anthropologists have written books on the topic.
But for Haiti things were even worse: The very slowly evolving Haitian ex-slaves society were subject
to frequent foreign occupations, finally by the Americans between
1915 to 1934, the US keeping fiscal control until 1947. And finally President Bush prohibited any”ex-migration" from the tiny Haiti to the US; a very small flow that the USA population would never have noticed... Haiti therefore did not fall down as it was kicked down while Chile
was held up because it had been helped by what Europe had the best to
offer, Democracy ( in spite of the "short Pinochet moment" and Christian Faith. There are some Chilean Philosophers of Democracy.
(( The "real practical scientific" question therefore is: "Why do these advanced countries - France and the US - blabber about "Helping a completely devastated, tent covered, Haiti, whose Political culture still suffers from centuries of mediocre administration? Why doesn’t the US bring many Haitians into their country for the months it takes to rebuild Haitian districts rather than move them from tents to tents? Financially, this would be less expensive way of reconstruction. It would also0 be a way of helping Haitian to see how real democracy works. ))
I agree therefore with the March 9 Op-ed page article “Give Haiti Control over its Recovery” but would add that the giving of the control should primarily aim at educating the Haitian to use well the aid they receive. One of the miseries is that the world has rushed into giving Haiti money, NGOs, etc…rather than the precious time needed to help the Haitians Help themselves, the most difficult task ever, of course.
(((On the basis of my knowledge of the Haitian situation and of my Christian Faith, I reacted to Robertson slogan that “God Had punished the Haitians" as follows: NO! The Loving Father, who sacrificed His Son, so that we Human realize at times that we must give ourselves up for the Poorest, this Holy Father
despairing of the truly sinful pseudo Modern French and Americans, send the Earthquake to the Haitians so that these “better powerful elites”” repair their old sins of only looking into themselves. Let us hope that the Historic incidence of Haiti be interpreted by all (Nonbelieving Humanists) in a truly useful way.
(((( I was thrilled Yesterday (March 8) when I heard in the Sunday`s Gospel that the Pharisees took Jesus to task by asking why “God” did not avoid evil: why HE allowed Pilate to kill Galileans or 18 persons to be by a falling tower in Siloe. Jesus answered Pat Robertson: Do you think these Haitians were more culpable than the inhabitants of Jerusalem (in the case of Siloe) or than those of New England or Chile?))))
Thanks and God's richest
Thanks and God's richest blessings to Sister Karen and her colleagues! They are performing the miracles of love and healing that Jesus began.
A wonderful, deeply moving
A wonderful, deeply moving statement.
Mercy Sr. Karen Schneider is
Mercy Sr. Karen Schneider is an angel in the trenches, along with the
children she writes about.
Bless her heart for giving this as a fund-raising talk.
This is the most heart-wrenching, most touching document I have
ever read in over 75 years.
It's too "bad" the distribution of her story is so potentially limited.
It might awaken us to what our emotions are really for and to then no longer
be able to ignore what we are doing to each other and to ourselves.
Thank God for folks like Sr.
Thank God for folks like Sr. Karen Schneider RSM. She and others are able and willing to do the work of us who cannot travel or physically help. Thanks too for spreading the faith of people who have so little of anything else.
I have emailed this to our
I have emailed this to our Canadian Governor General Michaelle Jean. She is a native of Haiti and is there now visiting the people working with the survivors of the earthquake. I felt it was important that she receive this heartfelt message from Sr. Schneider. Mme. Jean has been a fantastic Governor General. On the day of the earthquake she was reduced to tears and I am so glad she has had this opportunity to visit.
Thank you so much for sharing
Thank you so much for sharing these heartbreaking and inspiring stories, Sr. Karen.
What I do not understand is
What I do not understand is WHY a resettlement plan did not emerge immediately. America has many unused ex-military bases available for habitation. Why was resettlement NOT on the table? Why were teenagers being told that they future must be put on hold until a group of dysfunctional adults worldwide stumbled forward amid some strange policy initiatives?
I'm so lucky to have a home.
I'm so lucky to have a home. These children are realy brave and it just moves me that they still beleive in God after all they've been through.
Thanks, Sr. Karen, for
Thanks, Sr. Karen, for sharing these stories. God bless you.
Thanks, Karen, for you are
Thanks, Karen, for you are ALWAYS and ALL WAYS a Sisters of Mercy! How blessed the world is because of you and all others like you who truly follow the teachings and example of Jesus.
Thank you, Sister Karen!
Thank you, Sister Karen! What a gift to read these stories!
And the Vatican needs to
And the Vatican needs to INVESTIGATE American women religious because_________? This valiant woman puts Cardinals Rode and Levada and their yards of neo-con silk to absolute SHAME!
Very moving!
Very moving!
Thank you for these wonderful
Thank you for these wonderful stories of life and faith.
I'm proud to call you a
I'm proud to call you a sister in Mercy. Thank you, Karen...what a blessing you were to your people and it certainly sounds as if they returned the blessing a hundred fold.
Karen, Thank you for the gift
Karen,
Thank you for the gift that you are and for being Mercy to so many!
Thank you for what you do in the name of Mercy!
God's Blessings.
Post new comment