Twitter - Facebook - Email Alerts - RSS
Distressed assets: Women's lives in a bad economy
Home foreclosures are up. Stocks are down. And many countries around the globe have begun to see a rise in prostitution, domestic violence and other systemic abuses against women. People may talk about their retirement portfolios suffering, but the real distressed assets are women who carry some of the greatest wounds in this global recession.
How is the recession linked to a rise in violence against women? Abusive partners or customers of sex workers do not so much seek to be consoled, as to control. So as our economy spirals out of control, people feel powerless and, in turn, often seek to control something, anything, including women, and often violently.
Already, the wage gap between men and women spans 22 percent globally, with women earning 78 cents to every dollar earned by men, according to the International Trade Union Confederation’s study published this month. With decreased incomes and increased job losses, women are faring poorly and groups working with prostitutes report a rise in women entering the sex trade in order to help themselves and their families survive.
The New Zealand Prostitutes Collective has indicated a rise in women entering the sex trade since the global recession began, and a recent study in that country revealed 93 percent of sex workers named financial reasons as their motive for entering the field. The same is true across the globe. In Prague, a woman can make the equivalent of $150 for a half-hour of work at some of the more expensive sex clubs, whereas, the average yearly income for a teacher in the Czech Republic a few years ago was approximately $15,000.
In China, a woman may work in a factory 12 hours a day and earn approximately $50 a month or may enter the sex trade and earn the same amount in one day. Many Chinese women have families still living in the countryside whom they support. It is clear that the choice to enter the sex trade is really no choice at all.
As more women enter the sex trade in the economic downturn, competition increases and women find themselves capitulating to more risky situations in order to gain clients -- putting them at increased risk of violence in the process. A Project Manager at the U.K.-based Magdalene Group, which works with prostitutes, told a local newspaper two weeks ago that, “Violence is a form of control and I think the amount of violence used against sex workers will also increase.”
Not only do more women feel forced into an increasingly risky sex trade, but the economic recession is also linked to a spike in women experiencing domestic violence. News articles from Las Vegas to Niagara have reported increases linked to downturns in the local economy. The Pittsburgh Post Gazette reports that the National Domestic Violence Hotline observed a 21 percent increase in calls in September 2008 at the beginning of the financial crisis over the same month in 2007 and that more callers are linking violence to economic problems.
This rise is not limited to the United States. Countries ranging from Britain to Malaysia have expressed concerns that domestic violence incidents are increasing or will increase based on the faltering economy. For example, the Women, Family and Community Development Ministry in Malaysia recently added 50 male counselors to assist families with the stress and potential violence that changing financial conditions bring.
As world leaders seek solutions to the global economic recession, any solutions must be created from an understanding of the recession’s cost to women’s lives. With millions of women experiencing not only home and job loss, but violence, too, we can’t afford not to pay attention to the unique ways women’s lives are entwined with the fate of the global economy.
Nicole Sotelo is the author of Women Healing from Abuse: Meditations for Finding Peace, published by Paulist Press, and coordinates www.WomenHealing.com. A graduate of Harvard Divinity School, she currently works at Call To Action.




I'd imagine that the number
I'd imagine that the number of abortions would go up too. Odd they didnt think that was a problem.
So the Young Voices are
So the Young Voices are against prostitution??? I thought you were supposed to support women making their own decisions with their bodies, what if their conscience tells them to prostitute themselves is it okay then?
I cannot take these columns seriously about an issue like this when we know that this space has been used to support abortion just a few weeks ago. Since many abortions are done for sex selection, the ratio of men to women is unbalanced in many countries which leads to much of the abuse and sex trade you speak of, until you stop abortion this imbalance, and this violence in all probability will continue and escalate. Show you care and become pro-life!
Oh my gosh!!! FINALLY a NCR
Oh my gosh!!! FINALLY a NCR article that I agree with completely! Praise God!
Thanks to Nicole for a very good article!
What if...and I am really
What if...and I am really going far with this I know...women simply refused to enter the sex trade no matter how much easy money it would make? Suppose they took the stand that they would rather starve than do that?
That's where I have always felt I would stand if that was my choice, even if it meant that my children would starve with me. I would blame God for my predicament, and I would expect God to help me. If God wasn't up to helping, then God better get the keys to the pearly gates out, because we are coming. We all have to die sometime.
Hi Marie, I actually think
Hi Marie, I actually think you agree with the sentiments of the other replier...I hope you never have to make this decision.
I cannot imagine anything much more horrible than the de-personalization of rape, being forced into the sex trade or the fear of war and torture. They are all on the same scale to me. They are all someone deciding that the worth of your life isn't much. They say that many women in Darfur are raped when they go out to get firewood for their family. For those women, the choice is heat, light, warmth to cook food versus their own safety.
What is it about presenting a
What is it about presenting a different perspective that makes it seem as though one is condemning those who fall prey either to cultural forces or to overwhelming physical force?
I remember my mother telling me that she and her mother were threatened by Russian soldiers who came to her home during WWII and that they stared them down, but that other women were not so fortunate. She did not say of the ones who became victims, "they were treated in a dehumanizing way, so they were dehumanized and had no choice but to think of themselves as a sex objects."
I dare to say that those women who are attacked when they go out for firewood find strength that we cannot even begin to imagine finding in those circumstances. You might call it God at work. I don't believe they consider it a personally defining moment. I don't believe they come away from the experience necessarily feeling that they have no choice but to offer sex for food, water, and protection. When we see such arrangements, it think it is entirely possible that a good number of them are the result of emotional bonds that develop in battleground settings.
This is different from living in a culture in which women's roles are limited and where women see other women prospering when they subject themselves to the will of a powerful man. And that is still different from a woman asking someone for help and the someone coercing her into performing a sex act.
The author, Nicole Sotelo, has lumped a lot of circumstances together that only go together because they are examples of women being victimized. The fact that there is more domestic violence when there is economic stress in a household is really a separate issue from what happens to women in battle zones, which is still a different issue from what happens to women in cultures in which the limitations put on women's roles limit the routes they have to fulfill their economic aspirations.
In other words, I do not think women here in the US whose families are experiencing economic stress and who might have had a family argument turn physical are considering becoming prostitutes.
Marie, I agree with your last
Marie, I agree with your last statement but all too often loss of financial security is a true consideration in leaving an abusive partner.
Of course, there is the
Of course, there is the situation where we have an abusive partner, which I actually left out. These people are abusive even when the world is not experiencing hard economic times, and leaving them is not always easy, and not only because of financial issues.
"The author, Nicole Sotelo,
"The author, Nicole Sotelo, has lumped a lot of circumstances together that only go together because they are examples of women being victimized. The fact that there is more domestic violence when there is economic stress in a household is really a separate issue from what happens to women in battle zones, which is still a different issue from what happens to women in cultures in which the limitations put on women's roles limit the routes they have to fulfill their economic aspirations."
Actually, I think Nicole is quite astute in bringing these examples together - while each incidence she mentions is unique, they each represent a lack of respect for women's lives and well-being. Each incidence of violence against women points to a larger pattern of misogyny.
They have misogyny in common,
They have misogyny in common, but to claim these things happen to women because they are women leaves out the huge number of equally cruel and stupid things men do to men or that men or women do to children. In fact, the reproductive systems of people of both genders are their respective vulnerable areas. Therefore, I would say that this way of behaving is the result of a lack of respect for others, regardless of gender.
For example, I knew a young man whose mother frequently beat him and then threw him out of the home. I never saw any behavior on his part that would enrage a person. It seemed his mother was mentally ill. To survive, he found himself on several occasions having to trade sex with men for food and a place to sleep. I tend to think this is more common than we know.
Furthermore, while women are usually more easily injured in domestic violence incidents, domestic violence is not always just men assaulting women. It is also women assaulting men, and women assaulting children, and men assaulting children, particularly in those cases where circumstances create tensions that lead to violence, rather than where an individual has a tendency to be violent and abusive day to day.
So, while it is possible to say that misogyny exists, I do not think it is the real cause of any of the acts of violence. I do, however, think that those cultures in which women are prevented from engaging all their capabilities are driven by misogyny.
"I do not think it is the
"I do not think it is the real cause of any of the acts of violence."
I worked in a domestic violence shelter. It happens every day, every minute, in this country, and around the world. Statistically, women are the victims of acts of violence at the hands of men at much MUCH greater rates than men by women. At the root of these acts are the desire to maintain power and control over the victim.
So, you are saying that the
So, you are saying that the men abuse the women for philosophical reasons? Misogyny isn't exactly a psychological condition. If a male who is abusive in a relationship is not abusive to women in general, I do not think it can be called misogyny.
I wonder whether men who are abusive to those whom they perceive to be weaker than themselves are doing so for biological or psychological reasons. I doubt that they are doing so for philosophical reasons.
Nicole - thank you for a
Nicole - thank you for a great article. This artcile made me realize that even my own quests for control have the potential to cause violence to those around me.
Marie - I pray that you never find yourself having to make that choice. I might be warry of making such defninitive statements about what I might do in a truly desperate situation.
Of course, it is difficult to
Of course, it is difficult to be conclusive about one's behavior under all possible conditions. However, I am of the impression that in Africa, like elsewhere, it isn't always necessarily a choice between life and death that makes women willing partners to men who do not respect them.
Marie, I agree with your last
Marie, I agree with your last statement but all too often loss of financial security is a true consideration in leaving an abusive partner .
Post new comment