NCR on Kindle - NCR classifieds - YouTube - Twitter - Facebook - Email Alerts - RSS
Reporter's notebook: Trying to get into Bahrain
On a Saturday morning in late January, I received a phone call from Kathy Kelly, coordinator for Voices for Creative Nonviolence, inviting me to join a human rights delegation to Bahrain. The need was immediate, she said. Nabeel Rajab, president of the Bahrain Center for Human Rights, was requesting international observers to arrive before Feb. 14 -- the one-year anniversary of the country's anti-government protest.
Until three weeks ago, I knew nothing about the tiny island kingdom or the government crackdown on its Arab Spring revolution. The title of the one of the latest human rights reports on the country sounded ominous: "Bahrain: A Gathering Storm."
For more than a week, I deliberated the invitation. At 52, my wanderlust persists, but I am not brave by nature and I make decisions slowly. I understood Mr. Najab's request in principle: Bringing international observers to conflict zones is a basic technique of nonviolent intervention, and I had been a part of such initiatives in the past. The trip's costs in time and money were manageable and my husband wholeheartedly supported the mission. But its hastiness and many unknowns worried me, and I remained conflicted and afraid. What good could a handful of Americans do in Bahrain?
"You need to live more from your heart -- your deepest self -- than your head," Sr. Irma had been telling me. In this instance, I did not know what my "deepest self" was saying. Then during my morning quiet time, I read a passage in a book on prayer that described loving neighbors as the way to know the love of God.
"[A]nybody in the world may one day actually become my neighbor and ask from me in the name of God my personal love and service," the author wrote.
Days earlier, I had watched a YouTube interview with Dr. Fareeda al-Dallal, wife of orthopedic surgeon Dr. Al Ekri, one of a number of Bahraini doctors given a 15-year prison sentence after he criticized the government's excessive use of force in last year's protest. Like her husband, Dr. al-Dallal had been beaten and detained and was now speaking out about her treatment in police custody, demanding a fair trial for the imprisoned doctors. Of course she was afraid, she told the interviewer. But if she didn't speak out, who would?
"The international community is not with us," she said. "We have only God."
Late one Sunday night, I decided the signs were clear enough. I would go. Nabeel and Dr. al-Dallal were my "neighbors" in the world asking for help.
Preparations for the trip were easy and cheap. The cost of my ticket was covered and an email appeal to friends produced enough funds for my in-country expenses. I had been advised to dress up. The well-coifed traveler in coordinated attire might stand a better chance of getting through Bahrain International Airport than a shabby-looking peace activist. So I had my hair trimmed, purchased sunglasses and dress boots at a local thrift store and donned creased trousers on the day of departure.
At Amsterdam's Schiphol Airport, a transfer point on my journey, I attended Mass, where a devout Polish woman named Maria gave me a rosary for my expedition and promised her prayers. As the plane flew over the Syrian city of Aleppo, I continued to read from a country profile of Bahrain in preparation for the many interviews to come.
But I never got into Bahrain. My request for a tourist visa was denied at the airport. A dour-faced immigration and customs officer noticed that I had not listed a local phone number on my disembarkation card and became suspicious. (I had forgotten to record the number in the United States and a printout of my e-reservation for my hotel only provided an address.) He whisked off with my passport into a small office, where another duty officer -- there were many milling about that night -- Googled my name and discovered that I am a contributor to the National Catholic Reporter. Damning evidence, apparently.
The tired-looking officer who grilled me was gentle but persistent. Why had I come to Bahrain? Who had invited me? What did I plan to do while I was here? I was told that since I was a writer, I would have to apply for a visa from the Ministry of Information. I knew this meant certain refusal. For the past several months, Bahrain's Ministry of Information has been denying visas to human rights organizations and major news outlets, including The New York Times, Wall Street Journal, The Christian Science Monitor and Al Jazeera. Mr. Rajab's request for help from Kathy was an attempt to penetrate this government-imposed ban on foreign observers.
If I could provide the name of a local NGO (nongovernmental organization) that invited me, my questioner said, perhaps I could stay. In my backpack were the phone numbers of several Bahraini activists, but I would not divulge these. My visa was denied, and I had a 20-hour wait for the next KLM flight back to Boston.
I did not take my rejection personally. On the night I arrived, there were others, including a reporter from The Associated Press and another member from our team of human rights monitors, who never got past the customs and immigration booth. The following morning, while sitting outside the immigration office, I saw passports of varying hues getting whisked away. Among those scrutinized was a young British consultant for an oil company who frequently comes to Bahrain.
"It's never been like this," he fumed.
Through the large windows of the airport's departure lounge, I could see the skyline of the capital, Manama, in the distance, looking especially alluring in the morning sun. I thought of all the migrants who make it to the U.S. border only to be booted out.
"You should not have been asked to leave," said the Bahraini ticket agent as he booked my seat on a KLM flight back to Amsterdam.
"Well, apparently your country doesn't want writers visiting right now," I said.
Since it was the eve of the Feb. 14 protest, I asked him what he thought would happen tomorrow.
"Nothing, I hope," he said.
Then, looking over his shoulder to see if his colleagues were watching, he murmured, "I can't really talk about the situation here." This furtive exchange was my only interview in Bahrain.
I arrived home on Valentine's Day, the very day I expected to be monitoring a mass demonstration in Manama. My Bahrain odyssey had taken a grand total of 72 hours.
Although it was maddening to be denied entry, I do not regret making the trip. My husband, Scott, said that in war, if 10 people rush the ramparts and only six succeed, the campaign is not dismissed as a failure. Out of the 14 Americans who tried to enter Bahrain as human rights observers, three were denied entry and eight were arrested and deported, but only after they had spent several days in the country witnessing and reporting on the government crackdown of the predominantly Shiite rebellion. You can read their reports on the newly created website witnessbahrain.org.
While in Bahrain, the Americans connected with some extraordinarily brave pro-democracy activists, including the widely admired Rajab. These connections have enriched all involved and provide yet another example -- I have seen so many -- of how human beings breach the walls separating them from their neighbor. To observe, even from afar, how a handful of ordinary Americans were able to cast a bit of light on the situation in Bahrain was inspiring, and I am grateful for the privilege.
Moreover, my aborted trip unexpectedly took me to parts unknown. The journey provided an occasion to live by faith rather than analysis. Preparing for it required abandoning my usual preoccupation with outcome and following the clues of the moment. And that is new territory for me.
More:






You did the right thing. In
You did the right thing. In trying to be a witness for peace you gave from your need, you risked yourself, and you treated the people in Bahrain like Jesus incarnate. Thank you for being braver than I.
The United States fifth fleet and the U.S. navy's central command is in Bahrain. In polite parlance that tiny terrestrial aircraft carrier is far too "strategic" for America to tolerate the messy uncertainties of self-determination, dignity, and all the rights that we demand for ourselves.
Iran is not an existential threat to anyone, and Bahrain doesn't need to be subjugated by a U.S. puppet so I can feel safe from a manufactured threat.
Maybe my senator will listen to reason.
I'm sure Israel will be
I'm sure Israel will be relieved to hear your assessment that Iran is not an existential threat to anybody. Of course, that makes it hard to explain their chief Imam's statement that Iran will remove Israel like a "cancer from the earth."
I'm amazed at this article.
I'm amazed at this article. As a writer, and a Catholic at that, I would presume that you did more research on a country before you decided to write about it. What do you know about Bahrain other that what has been fed to you by Nabeel Rajab? Nothing! Do you know that there is large Catholic community (among other Christian denominations) here and that the very land the Sacred Heart church has been built on is a grant from the Al Khalifa family? Do you know that Bahrain is one of the most tolerant countries in the Arabian Gulf? Did you know that the former ambassador to the US was a Jewess? Do you know that we are free to practice our various faiths without restriction - except that the very people that you came to interview and support were the ones who do not tolerate us?
I'm sorry, but all you had to do was to pick up the phone and call the church here to find out the real truth.
Yes, there have been abuses and torture - from BOTH sides; not just the government! Nabeel Rajab is pretty good at using 'human rights' as a cover for his political aims and he has been encouraging youngsters to riot and cause mayhem, not bothered if they would get hurt in the process.
I am a Catholic myself and I feel sorry for the misguided people who are trying to ruin this country - aided and abetted by people like yourself in the West who have no idea what you are talking about. My connection with Bahrain dates back to the late 1950's to date when my Stepfather first came over here to work. I myself have been here since 1988 and I have seen and witnessed myself what is happening to Bahrain. Today, Bahrain is no longer tolerant, people distrust each other and we live in fear - not from the government but from these protesters.
Just a quick reply - you
Just a quick reply
- you said the ruling family donated the church! Where do they bring the money from?! Wake up, its the money of the people, money of the lands income from oil, good, aluminum, tourism and exports..
Who built the second if not first church in Bahrain? Go past Manama and you'll see ammerican mission hospital and church adjacent to each other.. Since 1900 Americans came and they wanted to serve Bahrainis so they created Yhis hospital with the school next to it which is called al Raja School..
I would unfortunately say, that giving a phone call to a local church would not be efficient and everybody knows why.. Giving statements against the government could lead to deportation of the minister and closure of the church! It happened before dear, they demolished 40 Shiite mosques in the country and this was reported by the independent royal commission to Bahrain by professor bissioni, please have a look at it..
I would not believe a church minister would give a false information but at the same time they do want to protect the church and our beloved christian citezents and residents .. At the same time, Jesus Christ was a man of peace, the same way he was targeted, people like Nabeel Rajab and other activist like AbdulHadi AlKhawaja are targeted.. So local churches will never give up these messages of peace and tolerance and they know that well, because they were neighbors to the same protestors, same Shiite clmmunities for the past 100 year and they know the real truth about the injustice they face ..
- my second point is, if the country is good, and the ruling family is complimented as you say, why would the government be afraid from reporters, journalists and human rights activists?! Why do they deport them, why, why and why?! The answer is simple, it's because they want people like you to be the reporters to the external community. It's because they want to hide the truth, they want the international community to believe that protestors are outlaws and immature; while all observers witnessed their maturity and their taken rights of freedom and equality.. How were chritisans chased during past millenniums, is the same here against human rights seekers... How would an international reporter harm the government, it's just by giving the real truth as they see it, and this is what the government want to hide..
Please look at all the news before October, and look how did the government lie, such as the people who dies in prison from torture, the interior ministry said they were sick.. So check that and check in October what professor cheriff Bissioni said.. It's the same news that the government was hiding and concealing .. The same this is happening today, as if no commission was formed .. In the eyes of the government and the ruling family is that all independent international organizations such as HRW and Amnesty ... Etc and all independent journals such as NYtimes and wall street journal .. Etc are a bunch of liars and this is why they are not given permission and I don't see it coming in the near future
The famous Arabic proverb says lie, lie and lie until people believes you,,, woe to all liars and all truth concealers.. Woe to whomever forgets messages of God for some benefits and interests ..
Thanks to all whom suffered to reveal the truth to the world .. Thatks to the national catholic reporter and the writer for trying to witness the crimes against humanity that the Bahraini government is continuing to do..
May God bless you for your
May God bless you for your efforts to live your faith and witness the suffering in Bahrain. Your journey was not in vain, and your blog gives us all hope that we might, in some small way, support the cause of freedom and justice everywhere there is need.
Your sister in Christ
Martha
Post new comment