NCR Today

NCR Today NCR Today is the group blog of the National Catholic Reporter. Our diverse team of bloggers has different interests -- the politics of the church and secular society (and the interaction between the two), culture, management of the institution, and more.
May. 25, 2012

'Philadelphia -- Another tough day on the stand for Msgr. Lynn

Charleston, S.C. -- Dispute over communion wine keeps chaplain out of jail

Lafayette, La. -- John Paul the Great Academy may lose its 40-acre campus before next school year if donors aren't able to quickly pool together enough money to buy the land and facilities that currently house the small Catholic school.

Opinion: Obama administration alienates Catholic voters by Michael Gerson

read more...   0 comments
May. 24, 2012

In his Washington Post column today, EJ Dionne discusses the public disagreement among the U.S. bishops about the lawsuit challenging the contraception mandate in the Obama administration's health care law. Bishop Stephen E. Blaire of Stockton, Calif., went public Tuesday in an interview with Kevin Clarke of America magazine. He expressed his concern that some groups "very far to the right" are turning the controversy over the contraception rules into "an anti-Obama campaign."

Blaire smells, quite rightly I think, the aroma of partisan politics in this lawsuit, and perhaps in the whole campaign about "religious freedom." At the very least, it can be used by the far right to try to defeat Obama.

read more...   0 comments
May. 24, 2012

I was at a fundraiser the other night for my state representative, a Democrat. He's a criminal defense lawyer, listens to my concerns about prison reform, gives me sound advice about the ways of the Missouri legislature, and follows through on his promises.

I was introduced as a Catholic sister to one of the state party leaders. He asked me right away about the Vatican investigation of nuns. I gave a vague comment about not worrying too much, that we nuns were all continuing our work. He, the Democrat, said it appeared to him the bishops were tough Republicans and that Missouri is likely in the next few years to grant nonpublic school scholarships, which would take even more money from the education of poor children and children with disabilities.

The two bills promoting scholarships did not move along in the Missouri bill process. But The New York Times ran a lengthy analysis of this movement last Monday.

read more...   4 comments
May. 24, 2012

It took more than 800 years for the church to formally canonize Hildegard of Bingen. Her elevation by Pope Benedict XVI was announced May 1 at the Vatican. The 12th-century German Benedictine abbess and mystic has been venerated for centuries by Christians, but the delay in her official recognition could have had something to do with her very unorthodox kind of sanctity.

At a time when two ecumenical councils were dissolving the marriages of all priests and cutting adrift their wives and children, Hildegard was proclaiming the special dignity of women in her speeches, books and music. She was, in fact, so far ahead of her time that she was neither understood nor taken seriously by the hierarchy, thereby avoiding for most of her life sanction or investigation. Here are a few of her positions on scripture and theology.

There exists in the inner being of God an almost erotic balance of feminine and masculine, which is mirrored in the complementary relationship of men and women.

Since Jesus took his body from a woman, it is woman rather than man who best represents the humanity of the Son of God.

read more...   6 comments
May. 24, 2012

This morning, Msgr. William J. Lynn took the stand for the second day in his landmark abuse trial in Philadelphia.

From the Philadelphia Inquirer:

During hours of tense testimony in a Common Pleas courtroom, Lynn tried to counter charges that he spent a dozen years burying sex-abuse claims and shuffling accused priests around the Archdiocese of Philadelphia.

He repeatedly told jurors that his bosses, notably Cardinal Anthony J. Bevilacqua, directed the church's response to child-sex abuse allegations, and he denied knowingly putting children in harm's way.

"I thought I was helping people," Lynn said. "I thought I was helping priests, and in those circumstances, I thought I was helping victims, as much as I could."

Lynn, 61, is accused of child endangerment for his role in recommending assignments to priests accused of past abuse. He is the first U.S. church official to stand trial for his role in the cover-up of abuse.

read more...   2 comments
May. 24, 2012

Here’s a story for critics of clergy sex abuse court cases who say “they’re only after the money.” From the Green Bay Press Gazette:

Brothers won't seek more from diocese
Documents reveal efforts to silence family

Appleton, Wis. — Two brothers who were sexually assaulted at the hands of a priest in 1978 said their civil lawsuit against the Catholic Diocese of Green Bay was about bringing long-held secrets to light, not money.

Todd and Troy Merryfield, who dropped a claim Wednesday seeking punitive damages, awards handed down in civil cases as punishment for wrongdoing. They explained pulling back the church's "veil of secrecy" is far more important than the $700,000 they were awarded already in the lawsuit after a jury decided Tuesday the church had covered up its knowledge of sexual abuse committed by the Rev. John Feeney before he abused the Merryfields.

The Merryfields implored the diocese to make public all it knows about past sexual abuses committed by clergy.

read more...   2 comments
May. 24, 2012

If you've thought the recent hierarchical flailing about -- going after nuns and Girl Scouts and issuing dire warnings about the death of religious liberty in the United States -- has a certain Chicken Little quality about it, the Knights of Columbus, the organization that is a principle engine behind the religious liberty campaign, has provided the words and images to confirm your suspicion. Except that the group's latest warning is no child's fable. It's downright dangerous.

As Steve Schneck, director of Catholic University’s Institute for Policy Research & Catholic Studies and a board member of Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good, explains:

The current issue of Columbia, the monthly magazine of the Knights of Columbus, should give faithful Catholics pause. The cover is Orwellian, featuring an illustration of an apparent cowboy, astride a black horse, with a 30-30 Winchester in his right hand and a large crucifix around his neck. Emblazoned in red across the bottom the words read: “Freedom Is Our Lives.” The issue is devoted to mobilizing Knights to fight for religious liberty against the Obama administration.
read more...   20 comments
May. 24, 2012

Cleveland Catholics demand Lennon reopen parish immediately

Philadephia -- Msgr. William J. Lynn took the witness stand at his landmark trial Wednesday, asserting he "did my best" to weed out sexually abusive priests. During hours of tense testimony, Lynn tried to counter charges that he spent a dozen years burying sex-abuse claims and shuffling accused priests around the Archdiocese of Philadelphia.

Philadephia -- Philadelphia Priest Takes Stand In His Own Defense At Child Sex Abuse Trial (Video)

Opinion: Is Catholic groups’ lawsuit against health law political?

read more...   1 comments
May. 23, 2012

Some crimes are so horrific that even the most Christian of hearts struggle to find forgiveness. On July 30, 2008, Vince Li beheaded 22-year-old Tim McLean, a fellow passenger on a Greyhound bus in Manitoba, Canada. A psychiatric assessment concluded Li was suffering from untreated schizophrenia. The murder was the result of a severe psychotic episode. He was found not criminally responsible and admitted to the Selkirk Mental Health Centre for treatment.

Public reaction continues to reflect misunderstanding of mental illness in general and schizophrenia in particular. When a review board first allowed Li supervised walks on the grounds of the Mental Health Centre, media focused on the anger and fears of local residents. The same review board has now recommended supervised walks in the town of Selkirk. Again, local media found no shortage of residents willing to voice their opposition on public airwaves.

read more...   6 comments
May. 23, 2012

Corpus Christi Parish in San Francisco's ethnically rich Excelsior District is spearheading community solidarity efforts to expose and combat the neighborhood's ongoing violence.

Largely with the guidance of associate pastor Salesian Fr. Jose Lucero and with the cooperation of the San Francisco Organizing Project, a communitywide gathering will be held at 11 a.m. June 16 as a follow-up to a May 9 interfaith prayer vigil for healing and peace in the parish hall that drew more than 70 participants, the priest told NCR on Monday.

"We should not have to walk in our streets paranoid. We are not going to stand for this violence. We are going to do something about it," Lucero told Catholic San Francisco, the archdiocese's weekly, in a May 18 article.

He said the meetings are opportunities "for us to speak, to not live in fear" and that "prayer is the most important way we can get rid of violence."

"This neighborhood in general has been affected by violence in different ways," Lucero told vigil participants, Catholic San Francisco reports.

read more...   0 comments
May. 23, 2012

From Reuters:

Former Guatemalan dictator Efrain Rios Montt will face a second trial on genocide charges after a judge ruled on Monday he could be prosecuted for ordering a 1982 massacre that left 201 people dead.

Rios Montt, 85, who ruled during a particularly bloody period in 1982 and 1983, is already facing trial on separate charges of genocide and crimes against humanity.

Read the full story here.

read more...   3 comments
May. 23, 2012

A nation-by-nation look at Arab Spring's progress

SETI Astronomer Jill Tarter Retiring After 35-Year Alien Hunt

Nuclear talks begin in Baghdad, a day after U.N. watchdog says deal with Iran is near

' Thousands of pages of confidential files for nine Franciscan friars accused of molestation tell the story of systemic abuse with the Roman Catholic religious order dating back decades. More than 4,000 pages of confidential files were obtained by The Associated Press before they are to be made public Wednesday.

read more...   1 comments
May. 22, 2012

Jim Arkedis of the Progressive Policy Institute says that Catholics -- one of the country’s most divided and complex voting blocs -- should be the swing voters of this presidential race.

A Gallup poll from April has President Obama and Mitt Romney tied among Catholics, 46 percent each. Arkedis writes:

"Perhaps no presidential candidate since John F. Kennedy has been able to unite this disparate flock. But President Obama’s task isn’t that tough. The key to winning the Catholic vote is to understand its composition — litmus-test abortion voters, moderates, women and Hispanics — and to aim to carry persuadable Catholics by healthy margins in crucial swing states. Failure to deliver them could cost the president re-election."

Gosh, he makes it sound so easy.

read more...   9 comments
May. 22, 2012

The Associated Press' Nicole Winfield is reporting from Vatican City this morning that the "head of the embattled Legion of Christ religious order admitted Tuesday to covering up news that his most prominent priest had fathered a child and announced a review of all past allegations of sexual abuse against Legion priests amid a growing scandal at the order."

Read the full story.

read more...   20 comments
May. 21, 2012

Notre Dame may falter on the gridiron but it's second to none in playing political football.

The university's announcement, with great fanfare, that it will join a suit against the Obama administration's modified policy that allows employees to obtain contraception without requiring Catholic institutions to foot the bill for it is the latest offensive.

Notre Dame and the others claim they would be forced to endorse practices that violate Catholic teaching even though the insurance companies themselves have agreed to pay for it. Presumably, they object to letting even non-Catholic employees simply process their claims on university forms.

University president John Jenkins denies this has anything to do with access to contraception. He echoes the "religious freedom" cry that argues that the Obama accommodation still ropes Catholic colleges into encouraging the very things the church abhors. Really.

read more...   17 comments
May. 21, 2012

Erstwhile NCR contributor Anthony T. Massimini sends word that he has started a blog in which he is writing a diary of his experiences at the Second Vatican Council. He attended the first session. The blog is www.the21stcenturyamericancatholic.blogspot.com.

read more...   3 comments
May. 21, 2012

My colleague, Michael Sean Winters, offers a critique of Archbishop William Lori's installation Mass homily, concludes that it was "bizarre" and ends his analysis: "The first reading yesterday was from Acts, recounting Paul's visit to Athens, and Lori used that as a metaphor for his own role, but instead of preaching Christi crucified and risen as Paul did, Lori preached Neo-con Constitutional Theory 101."

In 1972, the new archbishop of Cincinnati, Joseph Bernardin, centered his installation Mass homily on the Eucharist as the moral imperative for the life of the church and her members individually.

read more...   3 comments
May. 20, 2012

Two quotations to ponder this Sunday morning.

-- “If the church were my religion, I would have given it up a long time ago. All the mad and crazy popes we’ve had through history, decapitating the husbands of women they’d taken. All the terrible things the church has done. Christ is my religion, the church is not."

-- “To be narrowing the discussion and instilling fear in people seems to be exactly the opposite of what’s called for these days; all this foot-stomping just diminishes the church’s credibility even more.”

read more...   48 comments