The Independent News Source
Twitter - Facebook - Email Alerts - RSS
Anglican Roundup
by Joshua McElwee on Oct. 27, 2009
Printer-friendly version
Send to friend
PDF version
Looking through my news feeds this afternoon I've noticed that the new process to welcome Anglicans to the Catholic Church has garnered a lot of coverage today, in both the Catholic and mainstream press.
Here's a roundup of some of what I found most interesting:
- In The Boston Globe, John Carroll claims that the news heightens the debate between fundamentalist and rational religions and that "the survival of the human species is at stake."
- In The New York Times, Randy Cohen argues that it is "disheartening that the editorial pages of our most important newspapers did not castigate the Vatican’s invitation to misogyny and homophobia."
- And, over at the America group blog, Austen Ivereigh summarizes a recent ZENIT interview with the current head of the process for the conversion of Anglican priests at the Vatican, Msgr. William Stetson. Stetson argues that future seminarians in the Anglican rite, those not currently in the seminary process, "would have to be celibate."
That's just a sampling of what's being said. More to come for sure.




Rome is planning to establish
Rome is planning to establish "ordinates" (personal dioceses) for Anglican converts, but everyone is responding as if they were establishing an Anglican Rite on the Eastern model with a synod of bishops, a seperate code of canon law, and the ability to make their own liturgical decisions! Yes, a bunch of Anglican ordinates spread around the world could evolve into their own bishop's conference, etc. but all that is a mere far distant possiblity.
Look upon the ordinates as a solution to a bureaucratic problem of the Vatican, i.e. it would be very cumbersome to have an Anglican "Form" parish or two in many dioceses reporting to the Roman Rite bishop, so you consolidate them within a country in a working relationship to a national bishops conference, and the bishops and Rome have a more efficient way of working with people who come over, and that will be helpful to those who come over giving them a more consistent and supportive environment.
Again since there will be no Anglican Rite (i.e. synod of bishops, seperate code of canon law, etc) Rome will likely treat the Anglican Form of the Mass as an additional Form of the Roman Rite along side the Ordinary Form and the Extraordinary Form much as there have been various Forms of the Roman Rite for various religous orders over the centuries.
The person ordinates may provide Rome with a solution to their problem of bringing into communion the devotees of the Tridentine form, allowing them to set up an ordinate in each country to administer parishes that follow exclusively the Extraordinary Form. If the coming Apostolic constitution is more general in form rather than particular to the Anglican tradition, that may be the direction Rome is going.
Everyone is making too much of what may be really be just an innovative administrative process serving a real pastoral need.
Jack Rakosky
votfcleveland.org
Post new comment