National Catholic Reporter

The Independent News Source

Distinctly Catholic

Holy Thursday


Holy Thursday inaugurates the Triduum, the three days of ceaseless prayer in which the Church commemorates the Lord’s passion, death and resurrection. But, in a sense, the Holy Thursday liturgy frames the Triduum. Holy Thursday sets the stage for the passion, but it also points beyond Easter, and in both instances it does so by focusing on the Incarnation of Jesus Christ.

The Holy Thursday Mass recalls the Lord’s Jewishness. This is a Passover seder that he was celebrating with his disciples, recalling the deliverance of Israel from slavery in Egypt. Now, Jesus brings deliverance from the slavery of sin, and not just to Israel but to the whole world, and he does so by starting in the most human way possible, a celebratory dinner with friends. He calls attention to his humanity so that the full salvific effects of what is to come will be made clear: The Christ is here to save human kind and he can do so because he is himself human.

A Grim Anniversary


While much attention has been focussed on the one year anniversary of the oil spill in the Gulf, it is also the one year anniversary of Arizona's enactment of SB 1070, the restrictive, racist, anti-immigrant legislation. The National Council of La Raza has issued a report on the law and the copycat legislation that has followed in other states. Those who think Arizona's path is the path to follow should be forewarned: It only promises a lot of expensive litigation, a population outflow of both documented and undocumented workers, and a black eye in the image department as tourists choose friendlier locales.

Roy Moore For President?


The Albama judge who was removed from the bench when he refused to remove the Ten Commandments from the Alabama Supreme Court building announced his plans to seek the presidency the other day. The inimitable Dana Milbank has the low down. Funniest part of the story? Moore's website includes his birth certificate. Watch out Donald Trump - you have competition for the lunatic vote. And according to a post at Politico, a stunning 48 percent of expected GOP caucus voters in Iowa do not think President Obama was born in the U.S. An additional 26 percent were unsure. Somedays, it is just easier to be a Democrat than others.

Meyerson: Follow the Money


In this morning's Washington Post, Harold Meyerson points out that those who are panting after deficit reduction need to recognize that the source of wealth in America has changed over the past decades, and that the on-going disparities between the way investment income and wages are taxed is part of the problem. There is no FICA (Social Security) tax on investment income, nor any Medicare tax. This has to do with how these programs were originally devised, but there is no moral reason to reward income earned by the sweat of someone else's brow over that earned by one's own.

Celebration of Tenebrae expresses expectation, suffering


The Wednesday of Holy Week, at least at my church, features the celebration of Tenebrae, a deeply moving and ancient liturgy that combines the services of Matins and Lauds for the Triduum and anticipates them by one day. Tenebrae serves as a vigil for the Triduum. The beauty of the service is focused on the expression of two emotions that we moderns distinctly do not like to encounter: expectation and suffering.

Obama Hosts Easter Prayer Breakfast


President Obama held his second Easter Prayer Breakfast this morning at the White House. Of course, we have not even gotten to Good Friday yet, but the timing of the breakfast was apparently unavoidable. Yesterday, a senior White House official told NCR that the breakfast was held on the Tuesday of Holy Week at the request of ministers who were otherwise engaged on Easter. For clergy, of course, Holy Week is a hellishly busy week! Still, it is good to remember that setting the date of Easter was cause for great controversy in the early Christian church as some followed the Roman practice of celebrating Easter on Sunday while other Eastern churches followed the Hebrew calendar and celebrated it on the 14th of Nisan, no matter what day of the week it fell on. So there is at least an Eastern precedent for celebrating Easter today.

The Surprising Opposition to Pope Benedict


On this sixth anniversay of the election of Pope Benedict XVI, it is well to recall the sense of dread with which many of us on the more progressive side of things greeted his election. And, who can forget George Weigel opining that "the 'progressive' project is over."
I would submit that this sense of dread has not been borne out by the pontificate itself and that the wisest thing said on the day of Benedict's election was the sage observation that "Ratzinger the cardinal will not necessarily be a true guide for Benedict the Pope."
Indeed, within a year, it was the conservatives who were gnashing their teeth. I wrote an article for Slate that recalled Father Richard John Neuhaus's expressions of disappointment at what Benedict had wrought. Since then, the conservatives have continued to be disappointed. Even when Benedict does something they like, such as issuing Summorum Pontificum, which permitted all priests to say the Traditional Latin Mass, that decision has not been accompanied by any promotion of the Traditional Latin Mass. For example, Pope Benedict himself has never presided over one of the traditionalist liturgies.


Subscribe to Distinctly Catholic

Friends of NCR 300x80 web ad.jpg

NCR Email Alerts


In This Issue

March 27-April 9, 2015


Some articles are only available in the print newspaper and Kindle edition.